Most critics welcome The Bourne Supremacy as a forceful sequel, with praise centred on Paul Greengrass’s urgent direction and Matt Damon’s restrained performance. The handheld camerawork and rapid cutting give the action a physical immediacy that many find convincing, while the Moscow car chase draws particular praise for its pace and invention. Damon supplies a grounded presence amid the commotion, and several reviews find emotional weight in Bourne’s efforts to reckon with his past.
The disagreement is substantial, chiefly over whether that same restless technique helps or hinders the film. Some broadly favourable reviews find the editing confusing or showy, and opinions differ on how much room the action leaves for emotion. The Hollywood Reporter argues that the shaky camera creates distance from Bourne, despite intelligent performances. Slant Magazine is harsher about the characterisation, finding little psychological depth where admirers see a troubled, sympathetic protagonist.
The film builds on and exceeds the original Bourne Identity, delivering one of the finest big-budget thrillers in years through Greengrass's kinetic direction and Damon's underplayed performance. It mixes visceral action with emotional depth, ending on a quiet, touching note rather than a bang.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
23 July 2004 · Manohla Dargis
85*
The critic commends Greengrass's brilliantly paced and cut direction that captures Bourne's fractured sense of time and space, especially in the exhilarating Moscow car chase, and notes the film's unexpected moral resonance.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★★ · Adam Smith
80
Greengrass improves slightly on the original by delivering consistently exciting action without pushing credibility, thanks to his drama-documentary background. Damon impresses as the slick, silent, angry black hole of a Bourne.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
27 July 2004 · Scott Tobias
80*
The film steps up the efficiency of the original with dazzling kinetics and style, driven by Damon's relatable performance and a compelling identity quest. Greengrass brings purposeful physicality to the action sequences through jittery handheld cameras and purposeful fast-cutting.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
23 July 2004 · Stephen Holden
80*
The critic describes the film as reassuring post-9/11 entertainment comfort food and highlights its high-speed action realism, particularly an extended Moscow car chase, along with strong editing that sustains mood over plot.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
19 July 2004 · festival review
70*
Greengrass imposes a relentless pace that makes a virtue out of plot confusion and delivers visceral thrills in chase sequences, especially the Moscow demolition derby. The documentary-style camerawork gives the film a distinctive feel, though the emphasis on action leaves little room for humour or emotion.
Read the full review →Greengrass has made a much darker, murkier sequel that explores the human consequences of Bourne's past, with strong turns from the cast including Damon. However, it slows the pacing, features fewer satisfying action sequences and invites comparisons to the superior first film.
Read the full review →V
Variety
18 July 2004 · Todd McCarthy
70*
The critic finds the film an erratic but worthy sequel, praising Damon's signature performance and the atmospheric locations while noting that the hyperventilated editing can be confusing and overly showy at times.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
19 July 2004 · Michael Rechtshaffen
40*
The review finds the handheld shaky-cam approach creates an undesired distance between viewer and protagonist, rendering the film chilly and distant despite smartly choreographed moments. Performances by Damon, Allen, Cox and Stiles are praised as sturdy and intelligent.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
21 July 2004
35*
Greengrass replicates the first film's technical elements but fails to renew its indie idiosyncrasy or add psychological depth, resulting in a chilly film without dimensionality or sensuality. The central conflict with Bourne's guilty conscience sucks the air out of the picture.
Read the full review →R
RogerEbert.com
23 July 2004 · Roger Ebert
The critic praises Matt Damon's grounded performance as Bourne and the inventive action sequences that highlight the character's resourcefulness. Greengrass's serious treatment and strong supporting cast elevate the film above standard genre fare.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
13 August 2004 · Peter Bradshaw
The critic finds the film a wildly hectic and stroboscopically edited espionage thriller delivering deafening bangs for the buck. It is raucously and entertainingly put together, with Matt Damon effective as the paranoid super-freak on the run.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
10 September 2012 · MS
Greengrass proves adept at action in his Hollywood debut, building on the original with feverish handheld camerawork and frenetic editing that lend urgency and ferocious realism. The result is a relentlessly paced, non-stop chase movie with a singular killing machine we can feel for.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
13 August 2004 · ★★★★½ · Angus Wolfe Murray
90
The critic praises the film's intelligent plot requiring knowledge of the original, flawless performances especially from Damon, Allen, and Cox, and Greengrass's energetic and precise direction, highlighting the sensational Moscow car chase.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate