Critics’ reviews

The Celebration (1998)

10 reviews from 10 publications. Critics’ score 74: 4 positive, 2 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of The Celebration

74
Positive
4
Mixed
2
Negative
0

Most critics respond warmly to The Celebration, with praise clustering around its performances and its uncomfortable mixture of family tragedy and black comedy. The reviews find that Thomas Vinterberg keeps the birthday gathering tense while allowing humour to sharpen the distress rather than soften it. Supporters see the stripped-down Dogme 95 approach as crucial to the drama’s immediacy: the acting feels exposed, and the family’s respectable surface becomes difficult to maintain.

The main disagreement concerns whether those filmmaking restrictions reveal more than they obscure. The New York Times celebrates Vinterberg’s freedom from conventional storytelling, while Empire finds the shaky handheld images distracting despite the strong acting. Variety admires the invention but considers the film uneven and its destination disappointing. The spread runs from enthusiastic praise to qualified interest, with reservations centred on the story’s substance and the value of its abrasive style.

Los Angeles Times
16 October 1998 · Kenneth Turan
85*

A beautifully calibrated and carefully thought out film about a completely out-of-control situation, it is raw without being off-putting and wrenching without losing its sense of humor. “Celebration” allows the audience to share the same sense of emotional danger and uncertainty its characters feel.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
23 April 2002 · Keith Phipps
85*

Vinterberg uses the Dogme 95 restrictions to craft a powerful, naturalistic family drama centered on a patriarch's birthday gathering disrupted by revelations of abuse. The film stands out for its honest, darkly comedic, and humane handling of dark family secrets.

Read the full review →
Empire
1 January 2000 · Caroline Rees
60*

The film is a mildly intriguing, well-acted tale of family reunion and buried secrets, particularly strong in its performances. However, the Dogme 95 rules and shaky handheld cinematography distract from the content.

Read the full review →
Variety
18 May 1998 · festival review · Godfrey Cheshire
55*

A propulsively inventive but uneven family comedy-cum-melodrama that should score well in international fests and Euro sites. Ultimately, the story’s disappointing destination underscores that Dogma 95’s stylistic prescriptions have little to do with human truth.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
13 November 1998 · Roger Ebert

Thomas Vinterberg’s “The Celebration” mixes farce and tragedy so completely that it challenges us to respond at all. The long day’s journey into night is fraught with wounds that the farcical elements only help to keep open.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
· Peter Matthews

The critic notes the Dogme 95 style's contrived effects but praises how the stripped-down aesthetic forces strong performances that make the family drama feel like a near-documentary.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
7 October 1998 · NYT Critic’s Pick · Janet Maslin

Thomas Vinterberg’s “Celebration” is still a virtuoso feat. Mr. Vinterberg strips away the conventions of ordinary filmmaking and furiously devises new, unfettered ways of telling a story.

Read the full review →
Time Out
3 May 2011 · GA

The film is seen as entertaining black comedy about family abuse revelations at a birthday party, but less substantial or original than it aims to be; still, it is assured and abrasive without overstaying its welcome.

Read the full review →
Collider
26 October 2024 · Benedict Hudson-Laursen
90*

The critic calls The Celebration Thomas Vinterberg's finest and one of the greatest Danish films, an intensely morbid yet captivating story of family secrets and abuse revealed during a patriarch's birthday celebration. They single out the Dogme 95 handheld, naturalistic style for creating authentic realism and dark humor amid the discomfort, along with strong performances.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
19 January 2001 · Angus Wolfe Murray
70*

The critic portrays the film as a family gathering that exposes deep-seated secrets and hypocrisy through explosive confrontations during a patriarch's birthday. An aggressive handheld camera style is used to shatter illusions of respectability in this upper-middle-class Danish family.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate