Most critics respond warmly to The City of Lost Children, with praise concentrated on its surreal imagery, imaginative design and sinister fairytale world. The reviews repeatedly admire the blend of dreams, grotesque humour and Gothic fantasy, finding plenty of invention even when the storytelling proves less satisfying. Performances also draw praise for giving the elaborate surroundings a human centre, particularly through the relationship between the strongman and the orphan thief.
The main disagreement concerns how much emotional weight the story carries. Empire finds the central partnership touching and the plot involving, while RogerEbert.com admires the images but finds less reason to care about the narrative. Other reservations concern disjointed storytelling, visual gimmickry and a sense that the many ideas never quite come together. The spread runs from enthusiastic approval to mixed responses rather than outright rejection: critics largely agree on the visual imagination, but differ over whether it sustains a whole film.
