Most critics respond warmly to The Draughtsman’s Contract, with praise clustering around its barbed dialogue, painterly compositions and elaborate period costumes. The reviews find that Greenaway’s carefully arranged landscapes and verbal sparring make the country-house mystery funny and unsettling, with social cruelty beneath the polite manners. Many also welcome the demands it makes on its audience, treating its clues and unanswered questions as invitations to look more closely rather than obstacles to enjoyment.
The reservations concern how far that pleasure survives the film’s mannered storytelling, though the spread runs from enthusiasm to qualified approval rather than outright rejection. The AV Club finds it rewarding as a patterned puzzle but less successful as a straightforward narrative, while Empire praises the plot’s construction. The New Yorker offers the clearest dissent, suggesting that the superior tone can become boring and that the violence jars with the comedy’s artifice.
