
The consensus is strongly positive, with praise centred on Ralph Fiennes and the precision of Wes Anderson’s filmmaking. Most critics find Fiennes both sharply funny and unexpectedly moving as Gustave, giving the elaborate caper a persuasive human centre. The production design, intricate storytelling and comic timing draw repeated praise, as does the melancholy beneath the farce. Across the reviews, Anderson’s familiar style is widely seen as serving a warmer, more emotionally substantial story about loyalty, decency and a disappearing world.
The differences are largely matters of enthusiasm rather than outright dissent. Empire acknowledges that the degree of stylisation may divide viewers, while Collider finds the emotional bond between Gustave and Zero slightly calculated. The Playlist’s reservation is more practical: the pace slackens in the final third after a strong opening. These caveats leave a broadly consistent response, with even the more qualified reviews admiring the performances and detailed filmmaking.
L
Los Angeles Times
6 March 2014 · ★★★★/4 · Kenneth Turan
100
The critic calls it a four-star delight that elevates Anderson's familiar approach into magnificent entertainment. He singles out Ralph Fiennes' transformative performance as Gustave H. for giving the world heft and reality.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★★★ · Calum Baker
100
Baker states Anderson's meticulous style reaches its most complete expression in this poignant period comedy, with Fiennes' poised performance revealing emotional depths amid manic escapades. The screenplay, score, camerawork and overall artistry are praised as unmissable.
Read the full review →T
The Telegraph
· Jenny McCartney
85*
Wes Anderson's latest is a triumphant Nazi-era caper of loyalty and love set in a made-up alpine country. Fiennes invests his eccentric concierge with profound moral sense amid fading grandeur and encroaching thuggery.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
6 March 2014 · 5/4/4 · David Jenkins
80
Jenkins describes it as a sparkling, opulent caper with an endearing lead turn from Fiennes, full of Andersonian melancholy beneath the cartoonish romp. The meticulous production design and tonal balance are highlighted as strengths.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
9 March 2014 · Mark Kermode
80*
The film is Anderson's most tightly wound and funniest in years, an artfully precise comedy full of rapier-sharp wit. Ralph Fiennes delivers note-perfect timing as the charismatic concierge M. Gustave in a choreographed caper of art theft, murder and historical upheaval.
Read the full review →N
The New Yorker
7 March 2014 · Richard Brody
80*
The critic views the film as Anderson's artistic manifesto, exploring style, tradition, and decency amid historical upheaval. He praises the portrayal of Gustave H. and the concierges' code of conduct as a stand against catastrophe.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
6 February 2014 · ★★★★
80
The review notes the film's shaggy-dog yarn delivers laughs and energy, making it Anderson's most fun since Rushmore, with a manic streak and strong comic work from Fiennes. It is called familiar in style but refreshing in tone and one of his very best.
Read the full review →F
Film Comment
· Jonathan Romney
75*
The critic finds the film a refined, artificed work that successfully balances mechanical precision with indirect emotional and nostalgic content about lost worlds and memory. It singles out the layered narrative structure and framing devices for praise while acknowledging debates over its stylized approach to history.
Read the full review →E
Empire
17 October 2013 · Damon Wise
The Grand Budapest Hotel continues Anderson's upward curve with rich production design, a Russian-doll narrative structure, and Fiennes in a show-stopping role as the rakish concierge. It is stylised to a degree that may divide viewers but rewards those who enter its world, ranking among Anderson's better films.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
7 March 2014 · Philip Kemp
The critic praises Anderson's intricate, detailed fabrication of a fictional Middle European world as his most complete yet, with visual and narrative riches alongside an undertone of loss. Fiennes' polymathic, comic performance as the concierge is singled out as a standout.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
6 February 2014 · festival review · Todd McCarthy
The critic praises Anderson's sympathetic portrayal of Old World grace and refinement battling 20th-century totalitarianism through arch and sophisticated farce. He singles out the film's dense aestheticization, meticulous design details, and formal techniques like varying aspect ratios and stylized camera moves.
Read the full review →I
The Independent
6 February 2014 · festival review
The film is a whimsical thriller and might be Wes Anderson's greatest crowd-pleaser yet. It is warm, very funny, focused despite its multiple narrators and time periods, and propelled by kinetic energy; Fiennes gives a glorious performance as the vain but endearing concierge M. Gustave.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
7 March 2014 · Critic's Pick · A.O. Scott
The critic finds the film a delightful caper that deepens Anderson's signature style with greater ambition and emotional resonance. He singles out the inventive prison escape sequence involving pastries as quintessential Anderson.
Read the full review →T
Total Film
14 February 2014
Wes Anderson's follow-up to Moonrise Kingdom is arguably even better and his most adventurous yet. Familiar trademarks abound but unexpected moments shine, with strong ensemble work especially from Fiennes as the smooth-talking M. Gustave; fans will find him on dazzling form.
Read the full review →V
Variety
6 February 2014 · festival review
The critic hails the film as a captivating 1930s caper with sly intelligence and genuine soul beneath its artifice. He singles out Ralph Fiennes' brilliant, vital lead performance as the standout element.
Read the full review →C
Collider
7 March 2014 · A- · Matt Goldberg
90
The film is the platonic ideal of a Wes Anderson picture: vibrant, witty, pristine, and a wonder to behold, uniting his signature stylized world with the darkness of early 20th-century Europe through magic and melancholy. It excels in technical elements, design, humor, tenderness, and Ralph Fiennes' performance as M. Gustave, though the emotional core between Gustave and Zero feels slightly calculated compared to some of Anderson's other works.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
4 March 2014 · ★★★★½ · David Crow
90
The critic calls it a splendid and ambitious effort that is Anderson's most haunted and fully realized world to date. It singles out the central character study of M. Gustave, brought to life by Ralph Fiennes, along with the detailed fictional history and color palettes.
Read the full review →/
/Film
28 February 2014 · 9/10 · Germain Lussier
90
Anderson has made one of his best films by exploring storytelling itself through a self-referential caper that delights with absurdity and questions its own existence. The result is entertaining and fun on the surface while offering deeper implications about influence and originality.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
7 March 2014 · B+ · The Playlist Staff
83
The film is an apotheosis of Anderson's aesthetic with minute care in every frame and a glorious sense of detail that floods the screen. It fell slightly short overall due to a lagging pace in the final third and a comedown from its initial high.
Read the full review →H
HeyUGuys
6 February 2014 · ★★★★ · Stefan Pape
80
The film offers tender charm and ineffable beauty that could win over critics of Anderson's style. Fiennes delivers a nuanced performance as the meticulous concierge in this whimsical, dreamlike world.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate