Critics’ reviews

The Hurt Locker (2008)

17 reviews from 17 publications. Critics’ score 87: 9 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of The Hurt Locker

87
Positive
9
Mixed
0
Negative
0

The consensus is strongly positive, with praise centred on Kathryn Bigelow’s control of tension and the close attention to soldiers doing dangerous work. Critics repeatedly single out the bomb-disposal sequences for keeping space and action clear while making the danger feel immediate. Jeremy Renner’s performance also draws praise for conveying the central soldier’s appetite for risk without simplifying him into a conventional hero. Most critics find that the ground-level focus gives the film psychological force without requiring a broader political account of the war.

The differences are chiefly about what that narrow focus leaves unexplored, rather than whether the suspense works. The Hollywood Reporter admires the raw tension but finds little depth in the character analysis or moral stance. Eye for Film similarly praises the atmosphere and Renner while finding the story and characterisation thin. These reservations sit within an otherwise enthusiastic response: the disagreement concerns depth, not Bigelow’s command of action.

RogerEbert.com
8 July 2009 · ★★★★/4 · Roger Ebert
100

The film is a spellbinding war movie focused on the people in terrible danger rather than phony suspense mechanisms. It earns its real suspense through personalities and clear, intelligent direction that keeps space and action coherent.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
22 June 2009 · ★★★★/4 · Fernando F. Croce
100

Bigelow delivers a smashing piece of visceral filmmaking that gets closer than others to the tense, ground-level spectacle of bomb disposal in Baghdad. The film excels in its handheld action sequences and character focus while avoiding both recruiting pamphlet and antiwar tract extremes.

Read the full review →
Film Comment
· Amy Taubin
90*

The critic praises the film as both a structuralist war movie and an immersive high-anxiety experience. Bigelow excels at making viewers feel the adrenaline rush of war through kinetic camerawork and Renner's standout performance as the central bomb disposal expert.

Read the full review →
Little White Lies
28 August 2009 · 3/4/4 · Kingsley Marshall
80

The critic calls it a commendably mature response to conflict, closer in tone to Generation Kill than other Iraq war films. It singles out the well-paced action sequences and the complex, subjective portrayal of the bomb disposal team.

Read the full review →
Time Out
25 August 2009 · ★★★★ · Dave Calhoun
80

The critic calls it one of the better films about the US Army in Iraq, praising its expert management of tension combined with journalistic attention to detail. It singles out the fine distinction between heroism and heroics and the immersive, realistic depiction of the squad.

Read the full review →
Empire
29 July 2009 · Ian Nathan

The review lauds the film as a bruising, brilliant masterclass in tension and visceral participation in the bomb-disposal unit's daily hell, highlighting Bigelow's skill at stripping back style for docu-intense realism and Jeremy Renner's standout performance as a war-addicted protagonist.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
1 September 2009 · Guy Westwell

The critic praises Bigelow's confident direction and the film's genuine fascination with bomb-disposal procedures in a combat zone. It highlights the suspenseful set pieces and the film's willingness to confront the adrenaline and pleasure some men find in war without moralizing.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
28 August 2009 · Peter Bradshaw

Kathryn Bigelow delivers the most insightful Iraq war film yet, a blazingly powerful anti-war action movie that focuses on soldiers' experiences rather than political debate. The critic praises its unpretentious clarity, tense vignettes of bomb disposal, and ability to convey the agony and excitement of asymmetric warfare.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
3 September 2008 · festival review · The Associated Press

The film is tensely action-packed and muscularly directed but doesn't aspire to be the definitive statement on the Iraq war. It offers raw tension in its bomb-disposal sequences but provides little in-depth analysis of its characters or moral stance.

Read the full review →
The Independent
27 August 2009

The critic hails it as the best film yet to emerge from the Iraq war, praising its intense, ground-level focus on the terror of war and how soldiers cope with extreme pressure rather than broader politics. Bigelow is singled out for masterful tension-building through character-driven scenes and innovative camerawork.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
22 June 2009 · David Denby

Bigelow’s film is the most skillful and emotionally involving picture yet made about the Iraq conflict, narrowing the war to the existential confrontation of man and deadly threat. It is a small classic of tension, bravery, and fear that restores the wholeness of time and space in action filmmaking.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
26 June 2009 · A.O. Scott

The film is the best nondocumentary American feature yet about the Iraq war and a viscerally exciting, adrenaline-soaked tour de force of suspense. Bigelow distills the psychological essence and moral complications of modern warfare into brilliant, agonizing set pieces.

Read the full review →
Total Film
23 July 2009

The critic calls it the finest film yet made about the Iraq war, commending Bigelow for shifting focus to the soldiers themselves and crafting exhausting, edge-of-seat set pieces that immerse viewers in the battle like few war films since Saving Private Ryan, with special praise for Renner's superb lead turn.

Read the full review →
Collider
25 June 2009 · B+ · Matt Goldberg
83

The critic praises it as a good Iraq War movie that portrays soldiers as complex humans rather than saints, set directly in the action in Iraq. Bigelow's direction creates intense, pulse-pounding tension focused on the bomb disposal unit and Jeremy Renner's standout performance as an adrenaline addict.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
17 December 2009 · ★★★★ · Luke Savage
80

The film is called one of the best war movies of recent times for its focus on the psychological effects on soldiers rather than politics. It is bold and brave with thrilling set pieces full of dread, though it loses some atmosphere on DVD.

Read the full review →
Digital Spy
23 August 2009 · Stella Papamichael
80*

Bigelow delivers a gritty, relentless war film with intense visceral impact and memorable images. Renner is likable and effective in exploring the macho egotism and inner conflict of the lead soldier amid the chaos of Iraq.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
18 October 2009 · Stephen Carty
80*

The critic praises it as an impressive thrill-ride focused on the adrenaline and tension of bomb disposal rather than politics or explosions, highlighting the credible atmosphere and Renner's performance, while noting it lacks much story or character depth.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate