Most critics take The Limey for what it is: a slight revenge plot made sadder and more interesting by the way Soderbergh assembles it. The praise clusters around the editing, the scrambled timelines and the decision to use footage of the young Terence Stamp from Poor Cow as flashbacks, which several reviews single out as the film’s most affecting idea. The casting of Stamp and Peter Fonda as relics of the 1960s is widely admired, as is Ed Lachman’s photography, and the general reading is of a rueful, nostalgic picture about ageing and retirement rather than an action film. The reservations are about Lem Dobbs’s script, which even admirers find thin, and about whether the style carries more weight than the story can bear. The spread is wide. Empire dismisses it as stilted and overstyled, and Eye for Film finds Stamp wooden, a view no other review shares.
The critic describes The Limey as a terse and atmospheric crime film with an unusually vivid sense of regret achieved through submerged textures and cross-cutting timelines. It functions as a perfect storm of technique, intuition, and personal taste that opens a vortex of longing and nostalgia for lost cinematic waves.
Read the full review →