Most critics come down in favour, and the praise clusters on Timothy Dalton. The reviews welcome his flinty, serious Bond as a corrective to the later Roger Moore films, and several describe a return to proper espionage, with real jeopardy and a Cold War setting that grounds the action. The pre-credits sequence draws the most consistent applause, along with the aerial finale; Variety also singles out John Barry’s score and the practical locations.
The spread is wide, from those who call it a high point of the series to those who find it flat. Reservations cluster on the villains, which even admirers call colourless, on a convoluted plot that wanders between locations, and on a leading lady more than one critic finds irritating. The split is partly by date: the American reviews from 1987 are cooler, with Roger Ebert arguing Dalton lacks the humour the role needs, while later reappraisals are warmer. Slant Magazine dissents outright, saying Dalton never owns the part.
