Most critics respond warmly to The Lobster’s deadpan attack on the pressure to couple up. Praise centres on the absurd premise, the bleak humour and the cast’s refusal to wink at the material. Colin Farrell draws particular approval for his subdued, physically unglamorous performance, while several reviews also find unexpected feeling beneath the stilted exchanges and shocking violence. The rules of this imagined society give critics plenty to recognise about contemporary courtship.
Reservations cluster around the second half, where several critics find the writing less focused and the pace slower. The wider disagreement concerns how much warmth survives the film’s chill: Variety finds profound tenderness in the satire, while Den of Geek considers it too aloof and self-satisfied to explore its ideas deeply. The spread runs from strong enthusiasm to qualified disappointment, with even the more doubtful reviews generally acknowledging the strength of the central conceit.
A
The AV Club
12 May 2016 · B+ · A.A. Dowd
83
The demented deadpan comedy creates a fun-house reflection of dating culture through its oppressive dystopia of mandatory coupling. Colin Farrell excels in a frumpy, swagger-free turn as the sad-sack lead, though the satire weakens somewhat after the first hour shifts to the woods.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★★ · Calum Baker
80
This chilly, incisive sci-fi satire blends surreal wit and shocking violence in a near-future where singledom is outlawed. The stilted tone may challenge some, but it teases out affecting moments in its study of love’s mechanics.
Read the full review →T
The Telegraph
15 October 2015 · ★★★★ · Film Critic
80
Lanthimos’s absurdist comedy is like nothing seen before, a post-Tinder Buñuel that jarringly reimagines Colin Farrell and works through mad comedic alchemy with its ensemble cast. It attacks real fallacies about relationships and systems with slicing weirdness that feels emotionally authentic.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
15 May 2015 · festival review
70*
Lanthimos continues his absurdist black comedy-drama with trademark weirdness and stilted dialogue intact despite the bigger budget and cast. Pathos seeps through the unsentimental façade and the film’s committed belief in its dystopian premise.
Read the full review →N
The New Yorker
9 May 2016 · Anthony Lane
70*
The review commends the film’s tenacious grasp of absurdity and grave intent in satirizing couple-centric society, but notes it remains grim, spiky fare where laughs die quickly. It singles out the central conceit and performances for keeping a straight face while holding the world up to scorn.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
15 October 2015 · 3/3/4 · Trevor Johnston
60
Lanthimos delivers a dark dystopic satire that proves he retains his radical edge with a marquee cast. The film’s conceptual confidence and singular vision linger, though its drained emotion makes it easier to admire than enjoy.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
15 October 2015 · ★★★ · Peter Bradshaw
60
The film is an intriguing but flawed absurdist satire that starts hilariously in its hotel setting but loses focus and bite in the second half. Bradshaw praises the deadpan performances, especially Olivia Colman, and the eerie hotel premise while criticising the loss of rigour and new undeveloped characters.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
14 May 2015 · ★★★ · Dave Calhoun
60
The English-language debut mixes awkward chuckles with sinister chills in its surreal take on relationships and singledom. It engages for much of its runtime but struggles to sustain its sharp writing throughout.
Read the full review →E
Empire
16 October 2015 · Ian Nathan
The review describes the film as a surreal, Kafkaesque exploration of attraction rules that proves inordinately strange and tiresomely glum but hideously funny in spots.
Read the full review →E
Evening Standard
16 October 2015 · David Sexton
The critic calls it a brilliantly funny horror film about dating and the difficulties of coupling up. He singles out the original conceit and thorough execution as its strengths.
Read the full review →F
Film Comment
20 October 2015 · Yonca Talu
The critic describes the film as a Kafka-esque dystopian parable on romance and estrangement that draws striking parallels to The Trial. It praises the clinical narration and surreal portrait of an Everyman confronting a cold system, noting it achieves greater audience identification than Lanthimos's prior work.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
12 May 2016 · Justin Chang
The critic calls it a hypnotically strange and suggestive dystopian parable executed with rigorous illogic and formal control, praising its witty dismantling of modern courtship and the lead performances by Farrell and Weisz. It notes the film’s tenderness amid cruelty but finds the second act wobbly.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
15 May 2015 · festival review · Leslie Felperin
The director makes an effortless transition to the big leagues with this hilarious and haunting surreal parable about a world where citizens must find a mate or be turned into animals. It features an eclectic cast and richly rewards viewers with its absurdist comedy and fable elements, though it may disturb some arthouse audiences.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
13 May 2016 · Critic's Pick · A.O. Scott
The critic praises Lanthimos’s deadpan dystopian comedy as perhaps his masterpiece, highlighting its absurd regulated society where singles must find love or be turned into animals. Farrell and Weisz are singled out for their affecting performances amid the film’s blend of humor and grimness.
Read the full review →T
Total Film
15 May 2015 · festival review · Jordan Farley
The piece finds the high-concept satire smart, melancholy and wickedly funny overall but notes it drags in the final act after moving to the woods.
Read the full review →V
Variety
15 May 2015 · festival review · Guy Lodge
The review hails the wickedly funny, unexpectedly moving satire of couple-fixated society as a supremely singular Bunuelian fantasy that builds to profound tenderness. It singles out the ingenious lo-fi conceit, ensemble performances, and allegory for superficial contemporary courtship.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
10 May 2016 · A · Oliver Lyttelton
95
The critic describes the film as an uproarious yet deadpan satire on societal constructs, dating mores and power structures that is also a surprisingly moving love story. They single out the impeccable craft, strong performances especially from Colin Farrell, and its status as Lanthimos' most accessible and enjoyable film yet.
Read the full review →/
/Film
13 May 2016 · Angie Han
85*
The critic calls it must-see viewing thanks to its pitch-black sense of humor, keen insights into relationships, and aching romanticism. They single out the way the film strips the world down to its essence, revealing itself as tender, hopeful and original beyond its initial satirical premise.
Read the full review →S
The Skinny
7 October 2015 · ★★★★ · Philip Concannon
80
The absurd premise of finding a mate or facing transformation is played to deadpan comic perfection with a superb ensemble. It praises the potent mix of arch humour, shocking violence and perceptive commentary on relationships and society, despite a minor narrative misstep in the woodland section.
Read the full review →C
Collider
16 May 2015 · festival review · Talia Soghomonian
70*
The critic describes the film as a smart speculative piece with warped dark humor that satirizes society’s obsession with coupledom and procreation, highlighting Colin Farrell’s enthralling performance and the absurdist premise at the hotel. The second half veers into greater absurdity and loses some of its original folly.
Read the full review →N
NME
15 October 2015 · ★★★ · Olly Richards
60
The film is a surreal and unpredictable comedy that is extremely funny and rather poignant at times but turns into a less interesting drama after the first half. It singles out Colin Farrell's paunchy, sad comic performance as a highlight while noting the starry cast and refusal to offer obvious answers.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
28 September 2015 · ★★½ · David Crow
50
The review calls it a savagely blunt allegory about societal pressures on love lives and dating, with a strikingly clever premise and quirky world-building. It complains that the film remains too dark and self-satisfied to explore its ideas deeply, resulting in an aloof and cramped experience.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
13 May 2016 · Pete Hammond
The reviewer finds the surreal absurdity of the film has grown on him since its Cannes premiere, appreciating its unique concept and strong performances from Farrell, Weisz, and others. He recommends it for those seeking something bizarre.
Read the full review →W
The Wrap
13 May 2016 · Dave White
The critic views it as a deeply strange satire of relationships that highlights the absurdity and desperation in the search for love. He praises the chilly, bleakly funny tone and the performances, especially Farrell's.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate