The reviews split fairly evenly between warm and lukewarm, with nobody dismissing the film outright and nobody quite loving it either. The praise clusters on the effects department, which most critics credit with the film’s best moments, from the shape-shifting mummy to the swarms of creepy-crawlies, and on Brendan Fraser, whom several find a likeable, goofy hero. Stephen Sommers’s direction is generally called assured and rarely dull, and the Indiana Jones comparison comes up again and again, mostly in the film’s favour. The reservations cluster just as tightly: a weak, silly script, broad performances and stereotypes that more than one critic finds offensive. Sight and Sound thinks it trades the original’s atmosphere and mystery for a string of theme-park rides, and Variety finds no suspense in it at all. The Los Angeles Times reckons it harmless fun for teenage boys, which is roughly where the consensus settles.
Ebert finds the film good trash, cheering nearly every minute despite its flaws in script and direction. He singles out the fun action sequences and silly dialogue for enjoyment.
Read the full review →