Critics’ reviews

The Remains of the Day (1993)

10 reviews from 10 publications. Critics’ score 72: 5 positive, 1 mixed, 1 negative.

Back to our review of The Remains of the Day

72
Positive
5
Mixed
1
Negative
1

Most critics respond warmly to The Remains of the Day, with praise clustering around Hopkins’ disciplined portrayal of a butler whose devotion to service suppresses his private feelings. Thompson’s performance and the exchanges between the two leads are also widely admired. The reviews repeatedly commend the careful recreation of period England, while several find substantial political and psychological depth in the adaptation’s treatment of class, duty and repression.

The main division concerns how much feeling emerges from that restraint. Some critics find the film deeply moving; others remain absorbed without becoming emotionally involved. The Independent admires Hopkins but finds the pacing uneven and the soundtrack too explicit for material that needs subtlety. The New Yorker offers the sharpest dissent, finding the adaptation stiff, short on humour and emotionally unsatisfying. The spread is broad: admiration for the acting and period detail does not produce agreement about the film’s emotional force.

Radio Times
★★★★★ · Adrian Turner
100

This impeccable adaptation of Ishiguro's novel features Hopkins as the repressed butler and Thompson as the housekeeper he may love, framed in flashbacks as a study of class, power and politics. The 1930s-40s settings are immaculately staged and Ivory's direction captures every nuance with real backbone.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
5 November 1993 · Kenneth Turan
80*

The critic calls it a moving and carefully modulated picture that overcomes stodginess through miraculous acting by Hopkins and Thompson. He praises their tandem performance as the heart of the film and the team's skill at re-creating period England.

Read the full review →
Time Out
10 September 2012 · DW
75*

The Merchant Ivory team adapts Ishiguro's novel about class, fascism and repression with Hopkins as the fanatically devoted butler Stevens and Thompson as the housekeeper Miss Kenton. The film succeeds largely thanks to Hopkins' subtle, tic-filled performance, though emotional engagement remains difficult; the repartee between the leads brings it alive.

Read the full review →
Variety
24 September 1993 · Todd McCarthy
70*

The review notes the film's meticulousness and superior acting but finds it continuously absorbing yet lacking emotional resonance for full satisfaction. It singles out the top performances by Hopkins and Thompson along with the production's class and historical milieu.

Read the full review →
The Independent
12 November 1993 · Adam Mars-Jones
60*

The critic views the film as an ambitious but uneven adaptation that struggles with pacing and an overly explicit soundtrack, undermining its subtlety and emotional restraint. Hopkins delivers an extraordinary, richly disciplined performance that stands out amid the film's flaws.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
8 November 1993 · Anthony Lane
40*

The review finds the film a parable of excess control and professional pride but criticizes it as clunky and overly starchy compared to the novel, with performances that leave the central character unsatisfying. It singles out the Merchant-Ivory style for lacking humor and emotional depth.

Read the full review →
Empire
13 March 2007 · Angie Errigo

The review hails the film as another perfectly crafted Merchant Ivory production, beautifully detailed with strong performances, particularly Hopkins' remarkable portrayal of the repressed butler. It offers profound character study alongside commercial appeal.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
5 November 1993

The film is bound for box-office glory and awards success, with a tour-de-force central performance. Hopkins's restrained portrayal of the duty-bound butler is singled out as the standout element that elevates the Merchant-Ivory adaptation.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
5 November 1993 · Critic's Pick · Vincent Canby

The critic praises the film as a spellbinding tragi-comedy with psychological and political scope, adapted faithfully from the novel. He highlights its exquisite realization of themes of dignity, service, and feudal decline through the butler's story.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
14 January 2010 · James Benefield
85*

The critic calls it the finest hour of Merchant Ivory, with crisp unfussy direction by James Ivory, an intelligent script by Ruth Prawer Jhabvala, and impeccable central performances by Hopkins and Thompson. A devastatingly sad scene near the end ranks among the Nineties' greatest screen moments in this quiet, reflective and incredibly moving film.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate