Critics’ reviews

The Straight Story (1999)

11 reviews from 11 publications. Critics’ score 88: 8 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of The Straight Story

88
Positive
8
Mixed
0
Negative
0

The reviews are consistently positive about David Lynch’s quiet, straightforward account of an elderly man’s lawnmower journey to reconcile with his brother. Praise centres on Richard Farnsworth, whose naturalness and dignity make the emotion convincing without forcing it. Critics also admire the film’s warmth towards ordinary Midwestern people and the attention paid to the landscape. Its unhurried storytelling, careful compositions and wry humour are widely treated as strengths, with Sissy Spacek’s supporting performance drawing praise too.

The differences are mostly in enthusiasm rather than judgement: some critics find the simplicity deeply moving, while others offer more measured praise for its charm and sweetness. Sight and Sound notes the risk of excessive sweetness, even while praising the performances and Freddie Francis’s cinematography. The slow pace is acknowledged repeatedly, but generally as something Lynch makes work rather than a reason to lose patience. There is no substantial negative dissent in the supplied reviews.

Radio Times
★★★★★ · David Parkinson
100

Following Lost Highway, Lynch is in mellower mood with this whimsical road movie that slyly dissects middle-American mores. Farnsworth gives a dignified Oscar-nominated performance as the lawnmower-travelling farmer, supported by Spacek and eccentrics met en route; the stately pace is exploited to gaze fondly on life's pageant, including a brilliant crane shot.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
15 October 1999 · ★★★★/4 · Roger Ebert
100

Ebert praises the film as a moving, sincere story of an elderly man's journey on a lawnmower to reconcile with his brother. He singles out the authentic performances, especially Richard Farnsworth's, and the evocative portrayal of Midwestern kindness and landscape for particular praise.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
15 October 1999 · Janet Maslin
90*

Maslin calls the film a profoundly spiritual and triumphant G-rated work that holds audiences in thrall despite its slow pace. She highlights Lynch's unexpected success with straightforward, emotionally resonant material and Richard Farnsworth's natural, artless performance.

Read the full review →
Variety
24 May 1999 · festival review · Emanuel Levy
85*

Levy describes it as Lynch's simplest, most straightforward and mature film, a quiet and emotionally effective tale of reconciliation. He singles out Richard Farnsworth's charismatic, poignant lead performance as the film's shining element.

Read the full review →
Empire
1 January 2000 · William Thomas
80*

Lynch has cheered up after his recent dark films, delivering an exercise in strange sweetness that echoes John Ford at his most elegiac. The film follows an ailing old man's slow lawnmower journey across the Midwest to reconcile with his brother, highlighting the decency of ordinary people and carried by Richard Farnsworth's resigned, award-calibre performance.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
22 May 1999 · Peter Bradshaw
80*

Lynch's film is a sweet and disarming tale based on the real-life journey of Alvin Straight on a riding mower to reconcile with his brother. It is a simple film of charm and simplicity with a grizzled appearance by Harry Dean Stanton.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
· Kevin Jackson

Despite expectations of Lynch's trademark weirdness, the film stays straightforward and wholesome as its title suggests. The critic praises Freddie Francis's cinematography, strong performances especially from Sissy Spacek, and the moving tact of the brothers' reunion while noting the risk of excessive sweetness.

Read the full review →
The Times
21 July 2023 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher

Lynch abandoned surrealism for this traditional story of a sympathetic war veteran traveling on a lawnmower to visit his ailing brother. Farnsworth brings glassy-eyed dignity to the role in an elegiac portrait of a fading American heartland.

Read the full review →
Time Out
25 January 2012 · GA

Lynch turns humanist and produces a gem with naturalistic linear storytelling, elegant compositions and camera movements, subtle sound and music, and wry humour on small-town life. Farnsworth's charm and the film's deceptive simplicity and warmth make it one of Lynch's most satisfying movies.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
19 January 2001 · Angus Wolfe Murray
85*

Lynch tells a simple story straight without it becoming dull, resulting in a gripping film. Farnsworth delivers a magnificent, naturalistic performance that redefines superlatives, supported by strong work from Spacek.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
9 February 2026 · ★★★★ · Jack Hawkins
80

The film is an understated, elegiac road trip that avoids melodrama through natural performances and careful control of sentiment. Farnsworth's lead turn is highlighted as sublimely natural and powerful.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate