The reviews are consistently positive about David Lynch’s quiet, straightforward account of an elderly man’s lawnmower journey to reconcile with his brother. Praise centres on Richard Farnsworth, whose naturalness and dignity make the emotion convincing without forcing it. Critics also admire the film’s warmth towards ordinary Midwestern people and the attention paid to the landscape. Its unhurried storytelling, careful compositions and wry humour are widely treated as strengths, with Sissy Spacek’s supporting performance drawing praise too.
The differences are mostly in enthusiasm rather than judgement: some critics find the simplicity deeply moving, while others offer more measured praise for its charm and sweetness. Sight and Sound notes the risk of excessive sweetness, even while praising the performances and Freddie Francis’s cinematography. The slow pace is acknowledged repeatedly, but generally as something Lynch makes work rather than a reason to lose patience. There is no substantial negative dissent in the supplied reviews.
