Most critics admire this film, and the praise gathers around its look. Reviewers describe hand-drawn animation in watercolour and charcoal, in the manner of Japanese brush painting, with soft colours and loose, sketchy lines that leave the world looking fragile. Takahata’s direction is credited with giving an old folk tale real feeling: a foundling girl pressed into a life she does not want, read by several critics as a story about what is done to young women in the name of expectation. Many note that the sadness arrives slowly and lands hard.
The reservations are about length and pace, chiefly the middle section, in which the princess waits on her suitors. Even warm reviews call it too long. The Guardian and Sight and Sound find it drags badly there, and the Radio Times thinks it a little dull and too melancholy for young children. Otherwise the spread is narrow, with most reviews sitting close together near the top.
R
RogerEbert.com
17 October 2014 · ★★★★/4 · Glenn Kenny
100
The film is a staggering masterpiece of animation based on an old Japanese folk tale. It is both very simple and head-spinningly confounding, a thing of endless visual beauty that seems to partake in a kind of pictorial minimalism but finds staggering possibilities for beautiful variation within its ineluctable modality.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
16 October 2014 · A · David Ehrlich
95
A devastating and deceptively simple tale that delivers an emotional wallop on par with Grave of the Fireflies and stands as one of Studio Ghibli’s finest achievements. It matures alongside its heroine with astonishingly beautiful charcoal-and-watercolor animation and a broad humanism that empathizes with objectified women.
Read the full review →E
Empire
20 February 2015 · Dan Jolin
90*
The film is a unique, beautiful and endlessly fascinating work of art. It stands out for its soul-soaringly beautiful hand-drawn, sketchy watercolour visuals that contrast with Hollywood CG animation.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
17 October 2014 · Kenneth Turan
90*
The film is a marvel of Japanese animation, a hand-drawn, painterly epic that submerges us in a world of beauty. The delicacy and grace of its sublime imagery create an impact that couldn’t be stronger; it is a parable about what matters in life and what does not.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
14 October 2014 · Elise Nakhnikian
90*
The soft colors, graceful movements, and clean lines embody the ineffable beauty of life on Earth. The film offers a potent feminist critique of traditional expectations for girls through the heroine’s transformation and the spiritual costs of forcing conformity on children.
Read the full review →The film is a visionary tour de force, morphing from a childlike gambol into a sophisticated allegory on the folly of materialism and the evanescence of beauty. It takes hand-drawn animation to new heights of fluidity, inspired by Eastern brush painting.
Read the full review →A magical and melancholy gentler work whose expansive sadness sneaks up on the viewer. Its austere, simple hand-drawn animation creates a fragile, impermanent world that laments loss while celebrating humanity, with a refined sense of metaphor.
Read the full review →E
Evening Standard
9 June 2015 · Charlotte O'Sullivan
80*
Takahata has created a ravishing, technically perfect product filled with tender, humorous details in its hand-drawn watercolour scenes. The gentle daring of this offering makes it all the harder to say goodbye, despite the film being slightly too long.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
11 March 2015 · 4/4/4 · Anton Bitel
80
The critic praises the vibrant, bittersweet feminist adaptation of the folk tale and its undeniable visual beauty while noting the excessive length and ponderous pacing as flaws.
Read the full review →N
The New York Times
17 October 2014 · Nicolas Rapold
80*
The film finds a peculiarly moving undertow of feeling in a venerable Japanese folk tale about a foundling country girl who can’t shake a sense of being out of place. The critic notes the director’s artistry and feeling for the main character are deeply felt.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
17 March 2015 · ★★★★ · Alex Dudok de Wit
80
The critic calls it a delicate, muted film steeped in folklore that offers an achingly nostalgic meditation on love, age and departure from the world, though it demands patience.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
25 May 2014 · festival review · Leslie Felperin
75*
A lovely piece of work adapting the Japanese folk tale of a magical child who grows into an independent-minded princess. It showcases Takahata’s flair for expressing movement in standout sequences and explores themes of family norms versus self-expression.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
★★★ · Leslie Felperin
60
The critic notes the exemplary draughtsmanship and some exquisite sequences but finds the film overlong, a little dull and narratively alienating, with a melancholy ending unsuitable for younger children.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
19 March 2015 · Peter Bradshaw
50*
The film is a labour of love that looks amazing in its hand-painted style but drags in the middle section as the princess waits for suitors. Lush imagery offers consolation but the narrative feels too constrained until its moving final movements.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
20 March 2015 · Andrew Osmond
30*
The critic describes a delicate post-pastoral fairytale epic but finds it overly long and leisurely paced, especially in its mid-section dealing with suitors.
Read the full review →D
Den of Geek
16 March 2015 · ★★★★★ · Ryan Lambie
100
The critic calls it an ambitious, personal Studio Ghibli classic with a loose, expressive pencil-and-ink animation style. The film is praised as a moving allegory about the brevity and joy of life, with a heartfelt ending and sincerity that makes it almost heartbreaking.
Read the full review →H
HeyUGuys
13 March 2015 · ★★★★★ · Gloria Daniels-Moss
100
Takahata delivers a touching tale of love and loss with breathtakingly beautiful, abstract animation that mixes pastel watercolors and pencil etchings. The story balances deep sadness with moments of humor and visual splendor.
Read the full review →C
Consequence
5 December 2014 · A-
90
The film is an exquisitely drawn fable that blends joy and melancholy while highlighting simpler pleasures and the pains of societal expectations. Its minimalist Japanese aesthetic and patient storytelling make it one of the year’s finest animated works.
Read the full review →P
Paste
23 October 2014 · 9.0 · Geoff Berkshire
90*
Takahata delivers a defiantly idiosyncratic masterwork whose hand-drawn watercolor and charcoal animation achieves timeless beauty while advancing a message about a woman’s right to choose her own path. The leisurely pace and mature themes make it rewarding for adult viewers seeking something beyond typical animation fare.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
14 October 2014 · A- · The Playlist Staff
90
The film is a rich and rewarding, gorgeously impressionistic hand-drawn work with a strong feminist tone and meditations on mortality. It is meditatively paced with a slightly repetitive middle section but remains charming and experimental.
Read the full review →The critic calls the film an exquisite hand-drawn animated marvel and an instant Oscar contender that puts civilization on trial in an epic pastoral tale. They single out the confident watercolor animation that vividly brings the natural world and childhood miracles to life.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
15 March 2015 · Owen Van Spall
80*
The film offers a relatable, compassionately told story of youthful desire versus duty with exquisite, brushstroke-like animation that appeals to adults and younger viewers alike. It has real emotional heft but runs a little long at nearly two-and-a-half hours.
Read the full review →C
Collider
17 October 2014 · B · Matt Goldberg
77
The critic finds the film an enchanting folktale that celebrates nature through its distinctive sumi-e animation style and emotional depth. A minor complaint is an abrupt, under-setup revelation late in the story that briefly disrupts the flow.
Read the full review →N
NME
18 March 2015 · Nick Levine
75*
The review describes a warm and charming animated adventure with gorgeous hand-drawn visuals and a wistful score that keeps the folk-tale story engaging. It notes unexpected sad and strange turns but highlights the film’s nomination-worthy qualities.
Read the full review →D
Digital Spy
15 March 2015 · Simon Reynolds
70*
Takahata’s return is seen as a memorable, visually stunning addition to the Ghibli canon with elegant watercolour animation and a moving Hisaishi score. It is rewarding for fans despite some narrative drag and not quite matching the heights of the director’s earlier masterpieces.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate