Most critics respond warmly to Thelma & Louise, with praise clustering around Susan Sarandon and Geena Davis’s convincing partnership, Callie Khouri’s sharp dialogue and Ridley Scott’s energetic direction. The reviews find humour and feeling in the women’s friendship, and admire the expansive American landscapes. Several welcome the film’s reworking of the buddy road film around women, while others find its strongest moments in the leads’ relaxed exchanges rather than its more emphatic dramatic turns.
The disagreement concerns how convincingly that entertainment serves its account of female freedom. Time Out admires the performances but objects to stereotyped men and women whose strength depends too heavily on guns. Sight and Sound takes a more fundamental dissenting position, finding a conventional morality tale with a restrictive attitude towards women taking control. The spread is wide: enthusiasm for the acting and direction does not produce agreement about the screenplay’s psychology or politics.
