Critics’ reviews

Timbuktu (2014)

20 reviews from 20 publications. Critics’ score 85: 20 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Timbuktu

85
Positive
20
Mixed
0
Negative
0

The reviews are unanimously positive about Timbuktu, with praise centred on Sissako’s humane account of life under jihadist occupation. Most critics admire how deadpan humour exposes the occupiers’ absurd rules and hypocrisy without softening the violence. The desert imagery and carefully composed wide shots draw repeated praise, as does the attention to ordinary people’s dignity. Several reviews single out the mimed football match, while others emphasise the women’s defiance and the central family’s performances.

There is little substantive disagreement, and the differences are chiefly in emphasis. Some critics stress the terror and suffering; others value the comedy and the refusal to make the jihadists into stereotypes. The Hollywood Reporter acknowledges eccentricities but finds the imagery and characters compelling enough to carry them. Reservations remain scarce: even the less enthusiastic assessments praise the film’s calm compassion and sharp observation of cruelty.

Little White Lies
29 May 2015 · 4/5/5 · David Ehrlich
100

Sissako's film is a terse but poetic humanist masterpiece that exposes the irreducible humanity resisting ideological control through a mosaic of everyday moments amid extremism. It complicates primal emotions without manipulation, revealing the soft tissue beneath the armour of fundamentalists.

Read the full review →
Film Comment
29 January 2015 · Michael Sragow
90*

The critic praises the film's bracing originality and poetic response to the jihadist occupation of Timbuktu, highlighting its visual mastery, charged tableaux, and emotional depth in depicting oppression and human resilience.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
29 January 2015 · Betsy Sharkey
90*

The critic calls the film a provocative, sometimes satiric drama that indicts repression through absurd policies and personal stories under jihadist rule. It singles out the blend of horror and humor, the dignity of ordinary people, and the haunting cinematography of the desert setting.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
28 May 2015 · Nick Pinkerton
90*

Sissako portrays the jihadist occupiers as awkward mediocrities whose arbitrary rules lead to violence, showing moral intelligence in equating the fate of the guilty and innocent under their rule. The review highlights the film's ability to underscore the strangeness of events while maintaining faith in the audience.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
15 May 2014 · festival review · Deborah Young
90*

The critic finds the film a hard-to-forget poetic social outcry on jihadist excess in Mali, with soul-stirring imagery and strong characters that make it watchable despite eccentricities.

Read the full review →
Variety
14 May 2014 · festival review · Jay Weissberg
90*

The critic praises Sissako as one of cinema's true humanists for his subtle, empathetic drama that condemns intolerance without resorting to stereotypes. It singles out the film's stunning visuals, choral structure showing multicultural life, and discreet yet powerful handling of tragedy and repression.

Read the full review →
Vulture
28 January 2015 · David Edelstein
90*

The critic calls the film shattering and deeply humanist, praising its light touch and sympathy for characters amid dread, while singling out a long, grotesque wide shot of violence by a river.

Read the full review →
Empire
19 May 2015 · David Parkinson
85*

The tranquillity of a law-abiding Muslim family is shattered by gun-toting jihadists in this harrowing reflection on the 2012 occupation of northern Mali. It is exceptional human filmmaking.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
28 May 2015 · Peter Bradshaw
85*

The critic praises the film's complex depiction of bigotry and violence with moral authority and grace, highlighting its witty and subversive visual moments amid the portrayal of a traumatised nation. The one thing singled out for praise is the brilliant visual moments and sly scenes like the mimed football match.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
29 January 2015 · B+ · Ignatiy Vishnevetsky
83

The critic sees the film as mature polemical filmmaking that turns wry comedy about inept jihadists into terror, highlighting how farce becomes horror under ideological control.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
24 May 2014 · festival review · David Sexton
80*

The film offers a calm, attentive study of tyranny and unreason under jihadist occupation in Timbuktu. It is beautifully and gravely filmed, showing the dignity of the people and landscapes without agitation or campaigning.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
1 October 2014 · Chris Cabin
80*

The critic praises the film's fury and condemnation of jihadists who feign faith, singling out its peerless clarity on true faith and a standout long widescreen shot of a family conflict.

Read the full review →
Time Out
15 May 2014 · ★★★★ · Keith Uhlich
80

Sissako delivers an unflinching depiction of the perils of resisting extremism, juxtaposing cruel acts with poetic images while showing residents living under siege with quiet defiance. The film makes living itself feel like a curse in this context of terror and oppression.

Read the full review →
The Times
29 May 2015 · Kate Muir
75*

The review highlights the absurdity of the fundamentalist occupation through local perspectives and traditional life clashing with Sharia rules, noting ironic scenes like imaginary football and the film's relevance amid rising extremism.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
27 January 2015 · Critic's Pick · A.O. Scott
70*

The critic describes the film as an unflinching, quietly furious exploration of life under radical Islamist rule that examines absurdities with calm compassion. It singles out the film's examination of cruelty mixed with hypocrisy and its relevance to broader global issues.

Read the full review →
HeyUGuys
24 May 2014 · ★★★★★ · Jo-Ann Titmarsh
100

The film is praised for its elegant and intelligent portrayal of life under jihadist rule in Timbuktu, highlighting the corrosive effects of extremism on ordinary people. It singles out the strong, defiant women and the surreal football match scene as particularly evocative.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
2 February 2015 · Anne-Katrin Titze
85*

Sissako delivers an unflinching look at occupation and resistance, exposing the double standards and threats of the regime through layered storytelling. The review highlights the powerful depiction of women at the forefront of defiance against the fundamentalists.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
14 May 2014 · B+ · The Playlist Staff
83

The film is a distinctive, artfully crafted mosaic that humanizes stories of extremism with authenticity and emotional depth. It singles out the central family's performances and the balance of whimsy, surrealism, and brutality in its storytelling.

Read the full review →
Paste
25 January 2015 · Jeremy Mathews
80*

The critic praises director Abderrahmane Sissako's deadpan approach to the subject of jihadist occupation, which dismantles extremist ideology through sharp observations rather than overt emotion. They single out the film's success in humanizing the jihadist characters, revealing them as ordinary people with flaws and temptations.

Read the full review →
The Skinny
20 May 2015 · ★★★★ · Philip Concannon
80

Sissako highlights the absurdities and contradictions of the jihadist regime with comic effect while depicting the suffering of ordinary people with lucid anger; the film is an essential work and vital plea for understanding and peace, marked by deep wisdom, humanity and brilliant composition.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate