Most critics respond warmly to Wag the Dog as a brisk, cynical satire on political spin and Hollywood’s ability to manufacture a convincing story. Praise centres on the comic precision, sharp dialogue and performances, with Dustin Hoffman’s self-infatuated producer the most consistently admired element. Robert De Niro also earns approval, while the favourable reviews find the connection between media manipulation and political power both funny and disturbingly plausible.
The disagreement is over how hard the satire actually hits. Even some sympathetic reviews find its cleverness calculated and its cynicism too flattering to an audience that already distrusts politicians and the media. Others regard the premise as stronger than the finished film. The spread is wide: Time Out offers a marked dissent, finding the construction lazy, the skits soft and the leaps in the story poorly handled, rather than sharing the prevailing appreciation of its pace and wit.
