Critics’ reviews

Z (1969)

9 reviews from 9 publications. Critics’ score 82: 9 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Z

82
Positive
9
Mixed
0
Negative
0

Every one of the nine reviews is positive, and most say much the same thing: Costa-Gavras takes a real Greek political assassination and tells it with the pace and violence of an American thriller, and the result grips. Critics praise Raoul Coutard’s photography, which several describe as having the look of a documentary, and Françoise Bonnot’s editing for the momentum. Mikis Theodorakis’s score is singled out more than once for building tension, and Yves Montand and the supporting cast are credited with giving the film’s anger a human face.

The reservations are about how far to trust that grip. The New York Times, reviewing in 1969, thinks the film manipulates its audience and plays to its prejudices in ways that will be mistaken for fine art; Slant, forty years later, finds the reputation as an uncompromising thriller overstated and parts of it conventional. Even so the spread is narrow, and no critic argues it fails as entertainment.

Los Angeles Times
20 November 1997 · Kevin Thomas
90*

The critic hails it as a 1969 classic that is as exciting as a detective thriller and as authentic-looking as a documentary, plunging viewers into chaos with raw documentary realism and urgent style. It singles out the film's chilling depiction of how quashing dissent leads to a police state and its status as a profound human document with bravura style.

Read the full review →
The New Yorker
6 December 1969 · Pauline Kael
90*

The critic describes it as an almost intolerably exciting political thriller that builds tremendous tension while serving as a purposeful political act in a commercial package. She singles out its dynamic, robust photography and skillful use of melodramatic techniques drawn from American gangster films to expose fascist corruption.

Read the full review →
Time Out
18 April 2012 · DT
90*

Costa-Gavras' crowd-pleasing left-wing thriller recreates the 1965 Lambrakis affair and its uncovering of police and government corruption using American thriller techniques to gripping effect. Though conspiracies are now commonplace, it notes the film's original impact.

Read the full review →
Empire
21 July 2006 · David Parkinson
85*

The critic praises Costa-Gavras's film as a powerful and influential political thriller based on real events. He highlights the outstanding photography by Raoul Coutard and Oscar-winning editing by Françoise Bonnot as key strengths that influenced later thrillers.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
26 October 2009 · Bill Weber
70*

The film remains an eye-catching, fast-paced watch forty years on, but its reputation as an uncompromising thriller feels overstated. The critic singles out the core of idealism and fury, embodied in the resistance of ordinary people, as what overcomes its more conventional elements.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
9 December 1969 · Vincent Canby
70*

The critic calls it an immensely entertaining topical melodrama that manipulates emotional responses and appeals to prejudices in satisfying ways, likely to be mistaken for fine art rather than popular movie art. It notes the film's origins as a Jury Prize winner at Cannes and its basis in real Greek political events.

Read the full review →
Variety
31 December 1968 · Variety Staff
70*

The critic calls it a punchy political picture that mixes action, violence, and conspiracy on a robust scale, based on a real Greek political assassination but masked as fiction in an unnamed country. Director Costa-Gavras is praised for dynamic pacing without exploiting the material, with strong performances especially from Yves Montand.

Read the full review →
Collider
7 January 2025 · Cathal McGuinness
90*

The critic hails Z as the best example of the political thriller genre, praising its blend of thrilling suspense and bleak political commentary on dictatorship and corruption. The score by Mikis Theodorakis and Raoul Coutard's gritty cinematography are singled out for building tension like investigative journalism.

Read the full review →
Paste
26 February 2024 · Craig D. Lindsey
85*

The critic calls Z a savage yet entertaining political thriller and dark satire that remains highly relevant, crediting its taut pacing, set pieces, and bleak conclusion. The exhilarating score by Mikis Theodorakis and the performances (especially supporting turns) are highlighted for making the message film work as genre entertainment.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate