The reviews are unanimously positive. Most critics take Insecure as a confident debut that arrives already knowing what it is, and the praise clusters on Issa Rae’s voice: the dialogue, the mirror raps, and the way ordinary days in the life of a Black professional woman are shown without a lecture attached. The friendship between Issa and Molly is singled out more than once, as is the detailed picture of Los Angeles around the pair.
The spread is narrow, and nobody is unhappy. The cooler notices, from IndieWire and The Hollywood Reporter, find the LA relationship-comedy shape familiar and locate the freshness in who is telling the story rather than in what happens. The warmer ones, led by The AV Club, argue that the plainness is the point and that showing this life matter-of-factly is itself radical. The Ringer adds that the ensemble keeps it from being a one-woman show. It is a difference of temperature, not of verdict.
