The reviews split almost evenly, with two in favour, three mixed and three against, but they agree on what works. Larry David’s comic persona carries the series wherever it succeeds, and the best sketches are the ones that put him against a strong foil or let his pettiness collide with a large moment in American history. The AV Club singles out the pairing of David and J.B. Smoove as the liveliest thing in it, and Consequence has kind words for the production design.
The reservations cluster on the same faults: sketches that run long, jokes recycled from David’s earlier work, and a format that lacks the payoff of Curb Your Enthusiasm. Variety adds a complaint about political grandstanding, which it calls the show’s lowest point. The spread is wide. IndieWire and Consequence find it reliably fun despite the repetition; The Guardian finds it a stale shambles with little to recommend beyond one well-timed guest appearance.
