Critics’ reviews

Shrinking (2023)

16 reviews from 16 publications. Critics’ score 56: 7 positive, 3 mixed, 6 negative.

Back to our review of Shrinking

56
Positive
7
Mixed
3
Negative
6

The consensus on Shrinking is mixed, with critics sharply divided over its treatment of grief and therapy. Harrison Ford provides the clearest point of agreement: even several negative reviews praise his grouchy humour and dramatic weight. The ensemble earns broader approval, though enthusiasm for Jason Segel’s vulnerable lead performance is less consistent. Supporters find warmth, wit and an appealing group of characters, with some reporting that the series settles after a shaky start.

The disagreement centres on whether that warmth feels earned. Collider finds the performances and handling of grief convincing, while The i Paper sees an irritating, directionless series that lets its therapist’s unethical behaviour pass without consequences. Other reservations concern emotional montages, easy resolutions and an eagerness to please that softens the darker material. The spread is wide: what admirers describe as heartfelt comedy strikes detractors as sentimentality that avoids difficult questions.

Radio Times
23 January 2023 · ★★★★ · James Hibbs
80

The critic sees strong potential in the grief-driven dramedy and its ensemble, especially Segel and Ford, though it is slower and bumpier than Ted Lasso. Characters grow engaging over time.

Read the full review →
Empire
23 January 2023 · John Nugent
70*

The critic praises the tragicomic balance, Segel's vulnerable performance, and Ford's surprising comic turn as a grouchy mentor. It is sweetly funny and sentimental, though somewhat cosy and conventional.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
23 January 2023 · B- · Ben Travers
70

The series is too cute for its own good and its central character is often infuriating, but Harrison Ford's performance as the curmudgeonly colleague elevates the show significantly.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
27 January 2023 · C+ · Manuel Betancourt
63

The premiere episodes struggle to balance comedic and dramatic elements while questioning the ethics of the therapist's unorthodox methods; the critic prefers the focus on Harrison Ford's character over Jason Segel's lead.

Read the full review →
Vulture
27 January 2023
55*

The series has charm thanks to its cast and Harrison Ford in particular, but its aggressive desire to be liked and relentless focus on feelings and problems becomes grating over time.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
26 January 2023 · Angie Han
50*

The critic notes Ford keeps the wobbly dramedy afloat with strong turns, but the series is too eager to please and glosses over darkness, diminishing stakes despite endearing performances.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
23 January 2023
40*

The critic finds the Apple TV+ series sentimental and schmaltzy, making Ted Lasso look subtle by comparison, with plenty of promise but not enough bite. Strong performances, especially from Harrison Ford, are undercut by excessive emotional montages and lack of impact.

Read the full review →
Variety
23 January 2023 · Daniel D'Addario
40*

The critic finds the focus on grief and therapy makes for a tough, talky sit that feels pre-chewed and lacking texture. Ford has strong dramatic moments but Segel struggles to make the lead compelling.

Read the full review →
The i Paper
27 January 2023 · Rachael Sigee
30*

The critic finds the show irritatingly schmaltzy and directionless, with an unlikeable protagonist whose unethical behavior lacks consequences. Harrison Ford's grumpy performance stands out amid the uneven tone.

Read the full review →
Evening Standard
23 January 2023 · Martin Robinson
20*

The critic calls the series bad and overly sentimental, with mushy musical montages that undermine its promising premise and cast including Jason Segel and Harrison Ford. It fails to explore grief or depression meaningfully and comes across as cynical and nauseating.

Read the full review →
Collider
23 January 2023 · A- · Nate Richard
90

Jason Segel and Harrison Ford deliver brilliant performances in this earnest dramedy about grief and therapy. Ford especially stands out with his grumpy yet vulnerable energy, making the show one of the most authentic new comedies.

Read the full review →
Paste
23 January 2023 · 8.5 · Akos Peterbencze
90*

The series introduces a hilarious psychological vigilante in a witty, heartfelt package with irresistibly likable quirky characters. The well-balanced sarcastic humor rooted in pain and heartache, along with strong performances including Harrison Ford's, makes it a delight from the start.

Read the full review →
Consequence
26 January 2023 · B+
83

The new Apple TV+ series deftly explores the intersection of grief and humor through a delightful pairing of Jason Segel and Harrison Ford. Harrison Ford steals the show as the lovable crank Paul, providing the standout element in this codependent therapists' story.

Read the full review →
/Film
23 January 2023 · Josh Spiegel
80*

The series is a thorny but charming dramedy that becomes one of Apple TV+'s strongest and most winning shows after a shaky pilot. The critic singles out the hangout quality and the cast's ability to make viewers want to spend more time with the characters.

Read the full review →
The Ringer
30 January 2023 · Alison Herman
35*

The critic finds that Shrinking attempts to replicate the success of Ted Lasso but falls short, resulting in a disjointed dramedy with a flawed premise that neither effectively handles grief nor comedy. It singles out the tonal confusion and lack of believable reactions to the therapist's boundary-breaking behavior.

Read the full review →
NME
26 January 2023
25*

The critic finds the series clichéd and overly saccharine, calling it absolute guff that will give viewers a headache despite its warm-hearted comedy intentions. Harrison Ford's funny performance provides the main relief amid the sitcom self-awareness and quick resolutions.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate