The reviews are consistently positive, with praise centred on Pedro Pascal and Bella Ramsey’s performances and the growing bond between Joel and Ellie. Most critics find that the series works as a drama beyond its video game origins, giving its characters enough attention to make the horror matter. Its balance of fear and tenderness draws repeated approval, while the third episode attracts particular praise for expanding the source material into an intimate story of love and loss.
The differences are chiefly in enthusiasm, with reservations scattered rather than forming a shared objection. Vulture acknowledges familiar post-apocalyptic elements but values the patient attention to relationships. NME finds some supporting characters underused, despite praising the central pairing. The Independent offers more restrained approval, admiring the acting and production design while questioning the series’ moral consistency. The consensus favours its human encounters over any claim to novelty in zombie storytelling.
