The Pitt (2025)

The critic finds The Pitt a highly engrossing medical drama that captures the chaotic, unrelenting rhythm of an ER shift with strong performances from Noah Wyle and Katherine LaNasa. They single out its textured, unglamorous approach and dense storytelling as the main sources of delight.

The critic finds the real-time medical drama covers knotty issues but is derailed by soapy acting and thinly written characters. Wyle is a strong lead, but the show struggles between prestige and procedural.

The critic calls it a bold and elevated medical drama that is a masterful balancing act of character study, medical theatrics and social commentary in a real-time 15-hour shift. It praises Wyle's gravitas and humanity as the lead, the strong ensemble including Katherine LaNasa, and its handling of contemporary issues with gallows humour.

The critic finds the series starts choppy while establishing characters and situation but grows sturdy as a well-executed medical procedural with an effective real-time format. It praises the production design, ensemble performances once settled, and points about flaws in emergency medicine, while noting it benefits from but is distinct from ER.

The Pitt is the most immersive, authentic and naturalistic medical drama seen, a masterpiece that shows humanity at its worst and best. It stands out for its real-time format, graphic realism and compelling portrayal of hospital life and staff.

The review highlights the real-time format as a strength that delivers relentless pace and tension, likening it favorably to 24 while noting the show's ER roots and post-pandemic themes.

The critic notes it is worth the wait for UK viewers, praising the character chemistry, ensemble dynamics, and diverse representation while critiquing the slow pace in the early episodes.