Most critics agree on one thing: Kate Winslet is the reason to watch. Nearly every review singles out her chancellor as commanding, committed and willingly ugly, and several call the performance the series’ only real achievement. The production is generally found handsome, with strong dialogue and a good eye for the trappings of power. Beyond that, the reviews lean mixed to negative.
The reservations cluster on the satire itself. Most say the series does not know what it is satirising, that it notices things about power and fascism without saying anything about them, and that the comedy and drama pull against each other. The spread is wide, from Variety and Consequence, which find enough to recommend it with caveats, down to The Guardian, which calls the show confused and a wasted opportunity, and IndieWire, which says Winslet cannot salvage it. The British press, reviewing in April, is cooler than the American reviews of February and March.
