Most critics are pleased to be back in Gilead, and nearly all of them agree on why: Chase Infiniti, as Agnes, is singled out in review after review, with Lucy Halliday named alongside her in several as the second of the series’ two young leads. The praise clusters around the shift in perspective, from the handmaids to Aunt Lydia’s school for the regime’s daughters, and the reviews describe it as a coming-of-age story about indoctrination, friendship and rage, several noting a lighter, more teenage tone than the original without much loss of menace. The reservations come from two quarters. The AV Club finds ten episodes too many, with world-building that pads rather than deepens, and asks whether the sequel needed to exist at all. The Hollywood Reporter thinks the strong performances are hemmed in by the original show’s archetypes. Nobody is hostile, but the spread is wide, from warm approval to a shrug.
The critic calls it a stunning and exemplary follow-up to The Handmaid’s Tale, as well as a magnificent coming-of-age story about girlhood, survival, rage and friendship under Gilead’s regime.
Read the full review →