Most critics respond warmly to Years and Years, with praise centred on Russell T Davies’ writing and the family relationships that make its political and technological fears feel personal. The favourable reviews find humour, compassion and energy in the domestic scenes, and an unsettling plausibility in the near-future upheavals. Performances also earn praise, with The Independent singling out Emma Thompson’s portrayal of populist politician Vivienne Rook as particularly effective.
The spread is wide, however, and the central disagreement concerns whether the Lyons family remain convincing people amid so many topical crises. Even some admirers find their involvement in events contrived, while mixed reviews question the dramatic substance beneath the ambition and describe the storytelling as chaotic. The harsher responses find caricatures and an excess of issues; IndieWire sees a workable black comedy about comfortable, detached people, but little substance in the cautionary drama.
