Critics’ reviews

Years and Years (2019)

13 reviews from 13 publications. Critics’ score 69: 8 positive, 3 mixed, 2 negative.

Back to our review of Years and Years

69
Positive
8
Mixed
3
Negative
2

Most critics respond warmly to Years and Years, with praise centred on Russell T Davies’ writing and the family relationships that make its political and technological fears feel personal. The favourable reviews find humour, compassion and energy in the domestic scenes, and an unsettling plausibility in the near-future upheavals. Performances also earn praise, with The Independent singling out Emma Thompson’s portrayal of populist politician Vivienne Rook as particularly effective.

The spread is wide, however, and the central disagreement concerns whether the Lyons family remain convincing people amid so many topical crises. Even some admirers find their involvement in events contrived, while mixed reviews question the dramatic substance beneath the ambition and describe the storytelling as chaotic. The harsher responses find caricatures and an excess of issues; IndieWire sees a workable black comedy about comfortable, detached people, but little substance in the cautionary drama.

The Guardian
14 May 2019
90*

The critic hails Russell T Davies’ thrilling new show following one Manchester family through a realistically imagined near-future from 2019 to 2034. It singles out the writer’s trademark humour, compassion and kinetic energy for praise.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
21 June 2019 · Tim Goodman
90*

An ambitious, magnificent series that turns current political and technological anxieties into compelling, human drama centered on an extended British family.

Read the full review →
Variety
22 June 2019 · Daniel D'Addario
85*

The series is among the most emotionally involving and best of the year, centering on an ordinary family enduring rapid societal and technological upheaval through resilient personal bonds.

Read the full review →
The Independent
17 May 2019
80*

The review calls the near-future drama plausible and intriguing, praising how domestic detail and global trends are skilfully blended. It singles out Emma Thompson’s brilliant performance as the terrifying populist politician Vivienne Rook.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
14 May 2019 · ★★★★
80

The review describes Davies brewing an anxious concoction of big issues and future fears in the first episode. It praises the creation of fleshy drama with a beating heart that thinks big urgent thoughts.

Read the full review →
Vulture
21 June 2019
80*

It is a gripping account of a society’s existential crisis that remains compelling by focusing on one family, though it gets a bit ludicrous shoehorning everyone into current events.

Read the full review →
The i Paper
14 May 2019 · ★★★ · Adam Sweeting
60

The ambitious series about the Lyons family leaping through a turbulent future offers plenty to think about but the critic is not yet convinced it qualifies as great drama.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
24 June 2019 · C · Erik Adams
57

It nails the masochistic impulse to consume news but treats the Lyons family as caricatures and feels like it is sadistically frying ants under a magnifying glass.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
24 June 2019 · Ben Travers
30*

The critic finds the series only really works as a black comedy lampooning the well-off and out-of-touch, but is hollow as a cautionary drama overall.

Read the full review →
The Times
15 May 2019 · ★★☆☆☆ · Chris Bennion
30*

The critic finds sharp satire buried under an avalanche of issues in the overstuffed state-of-the-nation drama. It notes the writer’s skill but complains the drama is bursting at the seams.

Read the full review →
Paste
3 July 2019 · Shane Ryan
80*

The critic finds the series a riveting vehicle for pure dystopian dread, praising its step-by-step portrayal of societal decay and the unsettling realism that implicates comfortable viewers.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
14 May 2019 · Louisa Mellor
75*

Russell T Davies’ energetic new drama holds a mirror up to modern times and gets off to an audacious start full of chutzpah, but everything is underscored by bleakness.

Read the full review →
Digital Spy
14 May 2019 · Morgan Jeffery
60*

It is wild and ambitious, a show about everything all at once that is stunning but rather dizzying and chaotic, with terrific performances but some elements feeling lightweight.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate