Film review

My Life as a Zucchini

2016 · Directed by Claude Barras · 1h 06m · MPA PG-13

In a sentenceA care home with an emotional wallchart, which the adults watching may also find useful

AnimationComedyDrama

After an accident involving his alcoholic mother, Courgette (voiced by Gaspard Schlatter) is sent to a care home. The shy, newly orphaned boy wants to find friends, but the children around him bring their own experiences of hurt and abandonment. Among them are Simon (voiced by Paulin Jaccoud) and Camille (voiced by Sixtine Murat). The home has an emotional wallchart, giving the children a way to name their moods. Courgette begins getting to know the other residents and working out whom he can trust as they share the everyday business of living together.

Plays from YouTube when you press play; nothing loads from them until then.

Fi1m review

Claude Barras makes a moving stop-motion film about children finding friends after adults have failed them. It offers comfort too quickly in places, but Céline Sciamma’s writing and the expressive faces keep its warmth honest.

Claude Barras’s My Life as a Zucchini is a warm, frank film about children in care, with an occasional weakness for offering comfort too quickly. After an accident involving his alcoholic mother, Courgette has to learn how to live among other children carrying hurts of their own. This could be punishing material, especially for an animation that invites a family audience. The director makes room for jokes and ordinary friendship without treating the children’s histories as something embarrassing to hurry past. The result is moving, and mostly earns its hope.

The large-headed stop-motion figures, with their enormous eyes, are expressive enough to make long explanations unnecessary. David Toutevoix’s cinematography allows those faces to hold our attention, and the bold colours keep the care home from looking relentlessly bleak. An emotional wallchart is the most telling piece of production design: feelings have an acknowledged place here. We were moved by that small detail. Giving a child’s mood space on a wall makes the home’s kindness feel practical, something that can be repeated tomorrow.

Céline Sciamma’s screenplay is alert to how children can be blunt about things adults struggle to name. Its humour is welcome because the children are allowed interests beyond being unhappy, and because their friendships involve more than mutual sympathy. Gaspard Schlatter gives Courgette a tentative voice without making him helpless. Paulin Jaccoud as Simon and Sixtine Murat as Camille help give the group distinct personalities. The voice performances have enough awkwardness to keep the dialogue from sounding like adults demonstrating how sensitively they can write children.

At 66 minutes, the film has little room for repetition, and Valentin Rotelli’s editing makes its episodes feel connected without forcing every encounter into a large dramatic event. There is a useful stillness to the way it moves between the children and their daily lives. Sophie Hunger’s music helps the warmer scenes, though we occasionally wished it would leave the faces to do the work. The quieter passages work particularly well because Claude Barras trusts a modest exchange to hold our attention.

What does not quite work is the speed with which reassurance sometimes follows distress. The children’s pasts are severe enough that the brighter present can feel a little too carefully protected, as though another disappointment would be beyond what the film could bear. A few relationships would benefit from more time before we are asked to believe in their security. Brevity is usually a virtue here, but there are moments when another ordinary day together would have done more than another nudge towards feeling better.

That reservation matters, but it does not undo the care taken with the children. Within family animation, this is an unusually direct treatment of abandonment, and its humour never depends on making vulnerability ridiculous. The adults’ failures remain serious even when the children find something to laugh about, which is why the warmth seldom feels dishonest. We would share it with children, provided there is time afterwards for questions about the hurt that brought these characters into care.

Critical consensus AI synthesised

84
Positive
25
Mixed
0
Negative
0

The reviews are uniformly positive, with praise centring on the expressive stop-motion characters and the sensitivity of Céline Sciamma’s screenplay. Most critics find that the film treats childhood trauma frankly without reducing the children to their suffering, giving friendship, humour and small daily pleasures proper attention. The large-eyed figures earn particular admiration for conveying complicated feelings, while the writing is repeatedly credited with finding hope without pity or easy sentimentality.

The spread is chiefly one of enthusiasm, though there is a distinct disagreement about tone. The AV Club finds the contrast between grim backstories and insistently cheerful storytelling uneasy, admiring the bold visual design but judging the narrative lightweight and overly reassuring. Most critics regard that balance as a strength rather than a problem; Empire’s reservation is instead that the film’s 66 minutes end too soon, a measure of how few substantial objections recur across the reviews.

Little White Lies
1 June 2017 · 3/5/5 · David Jenkins
100

The critic hails it as a superlative family film that dares to engage with uncomfortable realities, singling out the stop-motion animation and screenplay for their magic and sensitivity.

Read the full review →
The i Paper
30 May 2017 · ★★★★★ · Matthew Turner
100

The critic calls the stop-motion animation an utter delight that deals with complex subjects from a child's perspective in a sensitive way, with brilliant writing, beautiful animation, and the power to provoke laughter and tears. It is described as one of the best films of the year.

Read the full review →
Film Comment
· Michael Sragow
90*

The critic calls the film a modest marvel that balances the difficulties and sweetness of childhood with sardonic humor and sensitivity. They single out its unsparing honesty about the kids’ plight alongside unabashed optimism about their courage and resilience.

Read the full review →
Financial Times
1 June 2017 · Nigel Andrews
90*

This Swiss/French stop-motion feature about a boy nicknamed Courgette in an orphanage is a little masterpiece full of charm, vitality and perfect scripting by Céline Sciamma. The large-headed Plasticine figures and sensitive handling of pre-puberty themes burst with expression and life.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
2 June 2017 · Peter Bradshaw
90*

This is a lovely little stop-motion animation about an orphaned boy and his friends in a care home, full of gentleness and traditional Frenchness. The expressive character designs and emotional wallchart stand out as highlights in this beguiling 66-minute film.

Read the full review →
The Times
2 June 2017 · ★★★★☆ · Kevin Maher
90*

This Oscar-nominated Swiss-French animation about a boy sent to an orphanage after a tragic accident with his alcoholic mother is a perfect, indelible portrait of childhood hardship and resilience. The huge-eyed Plasticine figures and sensitive adaptation by Céline Sciamma are singled out for praise.

Read the full review →

Cast

Awards

Academy Awards, 2017

Nominated
Best Animated Feature

European Film Academy Young Audience Award, 2017

Nominated
European Film Academy Young Audience Award

International Submission to the Academy Awards, 2017

Nominated
International Submission to the Academy Awards

Lumière Award for Best Animated Film, 2017

Won
Lumière Award for Best Animated Film

Annecy Cristal for a Feature Film, 2016

Won
Annecy Cristal for a Feature Film

European Film Award for Best Animated Feature Film, 2016

Won
European Film Award for Best Animated Feature Film

Lux Prize, 2016

Nominated
Lux Prize

If you liked this, try…