In a sentenceThe jungle makes a persuasive case for itself before anyone starts explaining it
Bill Markham (Powers Boothe) returns to the jungle year after year, searching for his missing son. Ten years pass, but he continues trying to bring the boy back to his family and Jean Markham (Meg Foster). The child grows from Young Tommy (William Rodriguez) into Tomme (Charley Boorman). The father’s search takes him among forest communities, their rituals and their relationship with the jungle around them. His wish to recover his child runs alongside a struggle over the forest and the people who make their homes there.
The photography makes John Boorman’s jungle adventure worth considering, despite its clumsy plotting and insistent moral lessons. Powers Boothe gives a father’s search the weight that the writing cannot always supply.
The Emerald Forest is an involving jungle adventure with an unfortunate habit of lecturing us. John Boorman wants us to question what counts as civilisation, and takes the plight of the forest seriously. The screenplay by Rospo Pallenberg too often simplifies the people who must carry those concerns. Its strongest starting point is also its simplest: a father returning year after year for ten years to find his missing son.
Powers Boothe gives the search a convincing weight. His Bill Markham has enough determination to hold our attention even when the plot becomes awkward, and the performance makes the father’s persistence comprehensible without making it seem easy. We felt for him, because the repeated journeys make a parent’s refusal to give up feel painfully costly. The film needs that human concern whenever its lessons about the forest threaten to take over.
Philippe Rousselot’s photography is the stronger reason to stay. The jungle has variations of light and colour that keep us looking even when the story has stopped surprising us; green need not mean visual monotony. The attention to ritual gives the forest communities a life beyond their function in the search, at least for stretches of the film. Simon Holland’s production design helps give these passages their physical interest, though the writing supplies less detail about the people taking part.
The music by Junior Homrich and Brian Gascoigne gives those passages a seriousness that largely works. It encourages us to attend to the rituals, although the film hardly needs further encouragement to be solemn. Ian Crafford’s editing gives the adventure enough forward movement to survive the screenplay’s clumsier passages. What it cannot do is make the switches between an absorbing journey and an environmental lesson feel consistently natural, and we sometimes become too aware of the point a scene has been arranged to make.
Charley Boorman is a less reliable centre as Tomme. There is an appealing openness to the performance, but also an awkwardness that becomes hard to ignore when the character needs more weight. The affection the film has for him does not supply the missing detail. Rospo Pallenberg’s writing gives the forest communities a related problem: they too often seem required to stand for a purer way of living, with too little room to be difficult, ordinary people.
An adventure can simplify a conflict without giving every character a complicated private life. Here, though, the forest communities are central to what John Boorman wants to say, so their idealisation weakens the film’s claim to take them seriously. We want to know more about these people than whether they confirm the director’s convictions. Try it if jungle adventure is a particular pleasure, with some patience for the lectures.
The reviews lean towards qualified approval, with praise clustering around the jungle photography and visual storytelling. Critics repeatedly single out the use of light, colour and movement, while the more enthusiastic accounts also admire the music and ritual detail. The adventure holds attention even for some who find the writing uneven. Praise for the performances is less consistent, though Powers Boothe receives favourable notice from Empire.
The spread runs from strong enthusiasm to mixed assessments, with no outright negative verdicts. Reservations centre on clunky plotting, thin characterisation and an environmental message that some find overly earnest or preachy. Slant Magazine offers a contrasting reading, finding thematic depth beyond a straightforward conservation plea. Charley Boorman particularly divides opinion: Radio Times finds his acting awkward, while Eye for Film considers him endearing. The latter nevertheless questions the tribal stereotyping, showing that sympathy for the film’s ecological concerns does not settle doubts about its portrayal of people.
Benson calls the film a powerful, beautiful surprise and suggests it may become a classic. She praises its vivid portrayal of tribal life, especially the lush cinematography, music, and ritual details.
Read the full review →Cumbow presents the film as a lasting, thematically rich work rather than a simple environmental tract. He praises its vivid use of light, color, and movement to challenge assumptions about civilization and nature.
Read the full review →The review finds the film engrossing despite flaws in its narrative and characterization. It particularly praises the film’s visual fascination, while noting tension between documentary realism and stylized direction.
Read the full review →The page could not be accessed, so the critic’s verdict cannot be confirmed. No specific praise or complaint is available from the supplied page text.
Read the full review →The accessible page identifies this as a film review but provides no critic's verdict. It contains no review text indicating what the critic praised or criticized.
Read the full review →Hutchinson finds the film’s conservation message strengthens its appeal, despite an overly earnest approach. He praises Philippe Rousselot’s beautiful jungle photography but criticizes Charley Boorman’s awkward acting.
Read the full review →
WalkaboutChildren encounter an unfamiliar landscape in a film less eager to explain.
Dersu UzalaFriendship and practical knowledge give its concern for the wilderness human weight.
The BearAn animal adventure that lets physical danger do most of the talking.
Princess MononokeThe struggle over a forest allows competing needs and uncomfortable sympathies.
Leave No TraceA father and daughter find that living apart from society has costs.
Free account
Two lists that know where things are streaming, collections you can share, your own score beside ours, and Discover that remembers what you have seen.
