Film review

Snowpiercer

2013 · Directed by Bong Joon Ho · 2h 07m · MPA R

In a sentenceTilda Swinton makes obedience look so disagreeable that the fighting starts to seem reasonable

ActionScience FictionDrama

In a post-apocalyptic future, a train carries a society divided between rulers and an underclass. Curtis (Chris Evans) wants to fight his way to the front, through carriages that keep the passengers apart. Edgar (Jamie Bell), Gilliam (John Hurt) and Mason (Tilda Swinton) are among those caught in the struggle. Getting forward means confronting the people who control the train, with little room to manoeuvre when the fighting starts. The dispute over who gets what becomes a battle over who gets to give the orders.

Plays from YouTube when you press play; nothing loads from them until then.

Fi1m review

Bong Joon Ho makes a brutal, inventive science-fiction film out of a train divided by class. The fighting sometimes goes on longer than the ideas need, but the cramped spaces and grotesque authority figures give it force.

Snowpiercer is a fierce, often funny science-fiction film that uses its train setting to make class divisions difficult to ignore. Bong Joon Ho puts resentment into confined spaces, where the distance between passengers becomes something people can measure and fight their way through. We recommend it, with a warning about the sustained violence and a reservation about how often the screenplay explains what the carriages have already made clear. Its anger is persuasive because the people exercising power can be ridiculous without becoming harmless.

Ondřej Nekvasil’s production design is crucial: the carriages make social position visible before anyone starts defending it. The grimy, retro appearance gives the machinery and compartments a used, inhabited quality, which helps an extravagant premise feel solid enough to accept. Hong Kyung-pyo’s cinematography makes the narrow spaces oppressive without reducing the fighting to an unreadable crush of bodies. We recoiled from the violence in those passages, because the lack of room makes each confrontation feel difficult to escape even before a blow lands.

Kim Chang-ju and Steve M. Choe cut the action with a useful sense of direction, maintaining the simple urgency of getting further along the train. That clarity matters when so much depends on understanding who stands in whose way. The quieter pauses are welcome, allowing the confinement to become unsettling without another fight being required. Marco Beltrami’s score helps sustain the pressure, although we would happily have traded some of that encouragement for more of the film’s uneasy calm.

Chris Evans gives Curtis the weight the film needs, keeping him serious enough that the surrounding absurdity does not dissolve the danger. His restraint occasionally becomes a limitation; the character can seem to be waiting for the screenplay to let him say more. Tilda Swinton, as Mason, has no such difficulty making an impression. Her performance is funny and repellent, and the director allows that comic ugliness to sit alongside the brutality without making the changes in tone feel like a mistake.

The weakness is Bong Joon Ho and Kelly Masterson’s insistence on spelling things out. The train already shows how a society separates its people, so the explanations can feel like interruptions from someone checking that we have understood. The humour generally does that work more efficiently, letting the people defending the arrangement make fools of themselves. At 127 minutes, the film could also spare some repeated violence without losing either its pace or its anger.

As science fiction, it asks us to accept an extravagant arrangement and then takes its consequences seriously. The pleasure lies in watching Bong Joon Ho move between ugliness, comedy and alarm without apologising for the changes. Those shifts can be rough, but they prevent the familiar struggle against an oppressive order from settling into dutiful heroics. The moments of stillness also give the performers a chance to suggest feelings that the more explanatory passages tend to state outright.

We would happily put up with the repeated points to spend another evening with Tilda Swinton’s Mason. The director gives the performers room to be strange, even when the plot is pushing hard towards its next confrontation. Choose it for the angry humour and the close-quarters action, provided the gore is not going to spoil the evening.

Critical consensus AI synthesised

77
Positive
13
Mixed
0
Negative
2

Most critics respond warmly to Snowpiercer, praising Bong Joon-ho’s combination of violent science-fiction action and class commentary. The train’s detailed interiors and grimy aesthetic draw repeated praise, as do the inventive fights staged within its confined spaces. The performances are another strength for many, with Chris Evans and Tilda Swinton singled out. Admirers find the film’s shifts between brutality, absurd humour and quieter feeling purposeful, and its social concerns give the action weight.

The spread is wide, however, with two negative reviews challenging that enthusiasm. Even favourable notices question the bluntness of the politics and the amount of violence. Time Out finds the storytelling rushed and some characters underdeveloped, while Slant Magazine argues that the treatment of exploitation is too simplistic to sting. The Wrap admires Swinton but finds the lead wooden and the film emotionally thin. The central disagreement is whether its action and political commentary strengthen each other or fail to cohere.

Los Angeles Times
26 June 2014 · Betsy Sharkey
90*

Korean auteur Bong Joon-ho combines a great cast, a gripping idea and a gorgeously grimy retro aesthetic to keep this eerie examination of the train wreck of humanity racing along. In “Snowpiercer,” Bong’s first English-language film, nothing gets lost in translation.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
26 June 2014 · A- · Ignatiy Vishnevetsky
90

The review describes it as a grim, grimy violent sci-fi action flick with a pessimistic political conscience and anarchist leanings that take over in the final act. It builds to an ending that displays integrity rather than conventional satisfaction.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
20 June 2014 · festival review
90*

The film works brilliantly as the sum of disparate parts adding up to cinematic excellence. It is wonderfully realised with strong purpose, beautiful design of the carriages and train exteriors, and a strangely moving allegory despite its gruesomeness.

Read the full review →
Variety
22 July 2013 · Scott Foundas
90*

An enormously ambitious, visually stunning and richly satisfying futuristic epic from the gifted Korean genre director Bong Joon-ho. The film has been brought to the screen with solid narrative craftsmanship, carefully drawn characters and respect for the audience’s intelligence.

Read the full review →
Radio Times
★★★★ · Stephen Carty
80

This is a thinking person's action film with effective world-building and thrilling, visually dynamic set pieces. Bong's direction is generally masterful with strong performances, especially from Chris Evans.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
23 July 2013
80*

Bong's first English-language film is an enthralling ride that examines social class in an engaging yet complex manner, with strong casting and enjoyable narrative momentum throughout.

Read the full review →

Cast

If you liked this, try…