Series review

Mum

2016 · Series · 30m · MPA TV-PG

In a sentenceTwelve months of tea, tact and Peter Mullan standing in a hallway not saying the thing

Comedy

Cathy (Lesley Manville) has just buried her husband. The first episode is the day of the funeral, and the family are back at her house for sandwiches. Her son Jason (Sam Swainsbury) is upstairs with his girlfriend Kelly (Lisa McGrillis), who cannot stop talking. Cathy’s brother Derek (Ross Boatman) has brought his new girlfriend Pauline (Dorothy Atkinson), who thinks the house is beneath her. The dead man’s parents, Reg (Karl Johnson) and Maureen (Marlene Sidaway), argue about the parking. Michael (Peter Mullan), her husband’s oldest friend, arrives, quietly makes himself useful and cannot find the moment to say what he has come to say. Cathy makes the tea. Each episode is one day, a month or more after the last, across the year after the death.

Plays from YouTube when you press play; nothing loads from them until then.

Fi1m review

Stefan Golaszewski’s sitcom about a widow’s first year, and the family who will not let her have it, is small, slow and extremely good. Its people are drawn thick and the first episode does not sell it, but Lesley Manville and Peter Mullan reward patience.

Stefan Golaszewski’s Mum begins on the day of a funeral and, for its first two series, hardly leaves the house. Cathy (Lesley Manville) has just buried her husband, and her family have come back to eat sandwiches and not talk about it. Golaszewski wrote all eighteen episodes and directed alongside Richard Laxton; his last sitcom, Him & Her, barely left a bedsit, and this one barely leaves a semi. It is quietly excellent, and the first episode does not make that obvious. The people around Cathy are drawn with a thick pen, and half an hour with them can feel like being stuck at somebody else’s wake.

Each episode is one day, a month or more after the last, and named for the month, so the first series is the year after a death told in six visits. The camera stays put: the hall with its coats, the kitchen, the strip of garden, the landing where people stop to say things they should not. Shots are wide and held, and nobody is cut to for a reaction. There is no studio audience, no laughter track and almost no music beyond Cat Stevens’ Wild World over the titles.

Manville plays a woman whose whole method of grieving is to be useful. She finds people’s coats, refills the kettle and takes each small insult with a nod. The joke is how much she is absorbing; the sadness is the same thing seen from a step back. Peter Mullan is Michael, her husband’s oldest friend, who turns up with a carrier bag, fixes whatever needs fixing and stands in the hallway wanting to say something. Mullan has spent a career playing hard men and plays a soft one here, and the two of them make a scene about a bus timetable carry more than most dramas manage with a deathbed.

The rest of the house is louder. Jason (Sam Swainsbury), her son, eats standing at the fridge and cannot see his mother. Kelly (Lisa McGrillis), his girlfriend, is the only person who actually talks to Cathy rather than past her, and she never stops. Derek (Ross Boatman), Cathy’s brother, wants everyone to get on and gets no one to; Pauline (Dorothy Atkinson), his new girlfriend, is a snob and the show’s villain in a good coat. Karl Johnson and Marlene Sidaway are Reg and Maureen, the dead man’s parents, whose arguments about the car park are the best-written nonsense in the series.

We laughed at Kelly in the first episode. Then, a few episodes on, McGrillis lets you see that Kelly knows exactly what everyone in that house thinks of her, and we stopped laughing and felt like Pauline. Turning a broad comic character into a person for ten seconds, then letting them go back, is Golaszewski’s best trick, and he plays it on nearly everyone. Not on Pauline, who stays dreadful, and whom Atkinson plays with such conviction that we came to look forward to her arrivals.

The flaws come with the method. The first episode leans on the types too hard: Jason’s gormlessness, Pauline’s face at the crisps. Several reviews of that opening half-hour found it soothing rather than sharp, and we can see why; the sharpness is in what accumulates. The repetition is deliberate, but it is still repetition, and there are half-hours in the second series where waiting for Cathy and Michael to finish a sentence feels like being kept in a queue. Against Him & Her, it is less rude and less often funny.

The Royle Family is the obvious ancestor, but Golaszewski has a story to tell, and by the third series, which moves the family somewhere we will not describe, it has become a love story that was under our noses from the first sausage roll. The last minutes of the first series, which we will not describe either, moved us more than a PG comedy has any right to. It was Manville’s face, one line and a door.

Watch it two or three episodes at a time, not six; this family are best in small doses, which is roughly what Cathy would say if anyone asked her. It first went out on BBC Two on 13 May 2016, and it has not dated by a day.

Critical consensus AI synthesised

74
Positive
3
Mixed
1
Negative
0

With only 4 reviews in so far, the lean is warm. Most critics find the series a truthful, gently painful comedy about grief, and the praise gathers around Lesley Manville, whose performance several reviews single out, with Lisa McGrillis also noted. The Guardian sees the warmth of the creator’s earlier work but finds this one more grown-up and less rude or funny; The Telegraph is the mildest, calling the opening episode soothing rather than biting and leaning on familiar sitcom tropes, though it expects Manville to deepen as the series goes on. The spread is fairly narrow, with nobody dismissing it.

Radio Times
13 May 2016 · Ellie Walker-Arnott
85*

The critic praises the series as a brilliant, truthful take on grief and the strange no-man's-land after losing a loved one. They single out its subtle, slow-paced observational comedy that is sofa-squirmingly painful yet emotionally charged.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
14 May 2016
70*

The sitcom shares the warmth and subtle characterisation of its creator's previous work, with believable characters and lovely performances, especially from Lesley Manville and Lisa McGrillis. It is a bit more grown-up than the prior series but not quite as rude, visceral, sexy or funny.

Read the full review →
The Telegraph
13 May 2016 · ★★★
60

The funeral setting offers family dynamics and dark comic potential but the episode is more soothing and enjoyable than biting, with some weak patches and familiar sitcom tropes. Lesley Manville's performance hints at greater depth to come as the series develops.

Read the full review →
Den of Geek
20 February 2018 · Louisa Mellor
85*

The critic praises the series as a very funny and affecting portrait of grief and family dynamics with subtle emotional insight. They single out the writing's light touch in revealing vulnerability beneath exaggerated comic characters.

Read the full review →

Cast

If you liked this, try…