In a sentencePooh is still good company, even when everyone insists on learning something from him
Christopher Robin (Ewan McGregor) is grown up and struggling to give his family the attention he gives his work. Evelyn Robin (Hayley Atwell) and Madeline Robin (Bronte Carmichael) share his adult life, far from the childhood games of the Hundred Acre Wood. When Winnie the Pooh (voiced by Jim Cummings) reappears, Christopher has an old friend to accommodate alongside his responsibilities. Pooh still belongs to a world of stuffed-animal companions, including Eeyore (voiced by Brad Garrett), and patient conversation. Christopher wants to keep his adult life in order, but the bear’s return brings his abandoned childhood back into it.
Plays from YouTube when you press play; nothing loads from them until then.
Jim Cummings gives Pooh the warmth this melancholy family film needs. Marc Forster is less sure what to do with the grown-ups, whose familiar troubles keep interrupting the pleasure of the reunion.
Marc Forster’s Christopher Robin is a gentle, uneven family film whose appeal depends heavily on already caring about Pooh. Its strongest idea is to let the reunion feel a little sad: Christopher has grown up, and the animals still offer the comfort of a life he no longer leads. There is something recognisable in that, especially for adults who have allowed work to occupy more space than they intended. The story surrounding it is considerably less interesting.
Jim Cummings gives Winnie the Pooh a patient, slightly puzzled warmth without making him sound as though he is dispensing advice professionally. The worn fur helps; this bear looks as if he has been held and carried about. We were unexpectedly moved by that careworn appearance and the tenderness of the voice. The animation allows the animals to seem vulnerable without demanding pity. Brad Garrett’s Eeyore is also welcome, his gloomy observations providing some relief from the encouragement to enjoy life.
Ewan McGregor is most persuasive when Christopher smiles at Pooh, allowing affection to replace the strain of being responsible. That small change tells us more than the film’s explanations of what he has lost. The screenplay by Allison Schroeder, Alex Ross Perry and Tom McCarthy gives him a familiar problem, then spends too long making sure we understand it. Work competes with family, childhood seems more inviting, and the lesson becomes clear well before the film has finished teaching it.
Matthias Königswieser’s cinematography sets the honey-coloured Hundred Acre Wood against the greyness of adult life, and the contrast is immediately readable. It also becomes a little insistent: the images leave Christopher scarcely any reason to prefer being grown up. Jennifer Williams’s production design makes the adult surroundings feel solid and orderly, but they are not particularly inviting places to spend time. The care taken with the film’s appearance is evident, especially in the weathered animals, whose worn surfaces make their return feel personal.
The workplace passages are where the film loses us. Their concerns are familiar enough to need little explanation, yet Matt Chessé’s editing cannot make them feel brief, and the busier plotting offers little compensation. The music by Geoff Zanelli and Jon Brion supplies warmth, though we found the voices quite capable of doing that work unaided. Pooh’s patient wordplay is enjoyable in small exchanges; when the film leans on it to explain how to live, the sweetness becomes wearing.
Marc Forster deserves some credit for allowing so much weariness into a family fantasy. The melancholy is not merely there to make the cheerful passages seem brighter, and the animals’ fragility makes the sadness more convincing. Yet the film is much less convincing about what an adult can do with that feeling. Its view of childhood risks making ordinary responsibility seem like a betrayal, which is a peculiar burden to place on a comforting bear.
Existing Pooh admirers have the clearest reason to spend 104 minutes here. Younger viewers may be less patient with all the grown-up worries, and the comedy rarely gets the freedom that might help them through. Choose it for a quiet, faintly sad reunion, with some patience for the office scenes.
The reviews are divided, with praise clustering around Pooh and his companions rather than the story built around them. Jim Cummings’s gentle voice performance, Eeyore’s dry humour and the stuffed animals’ careworn animation draw approval even from several detractors. Supporters find a comforting family film with an affecting sadness about childhood and adult responsibilities. The characters’ warmth and vulnerability are the clearest points of agreement across otherwise sharply differing responses.
Reservations centre on a familiar, contrived plot, uneven tone and workplace scenes that some find tedious. The spread is wide: what supporters describe as melancholy, detractors find bleak or joyless. /Film praises the honest treatment of adulthood’s competing demands, while Vulture argues that the film treats growing up as abandonment. Even Pooh divides opinion: The Hollywood Reporter finds that his initially amusing exchanges become aggravating through repetition. The consensus is mixed, with affection for the characters insufficient to settle doubts about the film.
Kemp finds the film big-hearted and energetic, though its overstuffed plot and low-stakes antics can feel messy. She praises the tender voice performance of Jim Cummings as Pooh and the vulnerability of the other characters.
Read the full review →The critic calls the film a bittersweet delight and a comforting, nostalgic family film. Pooh is singled out as its standout, while the lovingly crafted simplicity and cast also earn praise.
Read the full review →Pinkerton finds the film mellow, melancholy and diverting, while noting its familiar premise. He praises the animated characters’ charm and the wordplay, especially the lines delivered by Pooh and Eeyore.
Read the full review →The review finds the film wistful but ultimately held back by a familiar, formulaic story. It praises the emotional effect of seeing Pooh and the other well-worn stuffed animals return to the Hundred Acre Wood.
Read the full review →Brody finds the film’s predictable story elevated by its abrasive, eccentric qualities. He especially praises Eeyore’s cynical asides, which add comedy and deepen the film’s vision of childhood.
Read the full review →The accessible excerpt does not reveal the critic’s overall verdict. It frames the film around the collision between Milne’s world and adult realities.
Read the full review →
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh · not reviewed yetThe bear’s unhurried conversations have more room, with fewer grown-up lessons attached.
My Neighbour TotoroA gentler encounter between family worries and creatures who need little explanation.
Ernest & CelestineAn unlikely friendship, softly drawn, with more curiosity about its animal companions.
Paddington 2Another courteous bear among busy adults, with firmer plotting and livelier comic timing.
Harvey · not reviewed yetFor adults, another gentle companion whose company makes practical people rather uneasy.
Free account
Two lists that know where things are streaming, collections you can share, your own score beside ours, and Discover that remembers what you have seen.
