In a sentenceSeven episodes is a long family visit, but Florence Pugh and Hoon Lee make it worth staying
Cathy Ames (Florence Pugh), Adam Trask (Christopher Abbott) and Charles Trask (Mike Faist) are among the central characters in East of Eden, a seven-episode drama created by Zoe Kazan. The cast also includes Joseph Zada as Cal Trask, Hoon Lee as Lee and Ciarán Hinds as Samuel Hamilton, alongside Robert Morgan as Sheriff Quinn, Anita Hegh as Liza Hamilton and Vaughan Reilly as Adolescent Cathy. Laure de Clermont-Tonnerre and Garth Davis direct, with writing credits for Zoe Kazan and Alexander Chee.
Plays from YouTube when you press play; nothing loads from them until then.
East of Eden is a rewarding family drama, carried by Florence Pugh and Hoon Lee. Uneven character development limits its ambitions, but the performances give us good reason to stay for all seven episodes.
East of Eden is worth the seven-episode commitment, chiefly for Florence Pugh and Hoon Lee, with a reservation about uneven character development. Zoe Kazan’s series gives its family saga room to examine why people behave as they do. Its strongest performances make that attention rewarding, even when the writing has not quite worked out everything it wants to say. We recommend it warmly, provided the attraction is complicated people rather than a comprehensive explanation of what makes them complicated.
Florence Pugh’s Cathy Ames is the chief attraction, unsettling enough to resist easy sympathy and compelling enough to hold our attention. The performance makes spending time with a difficult character worthwhile without requiring us to excuse her. Zoe Kazan and Alexander Chee, the credited writers, give Cathy considerable attention, but not always sufficient development; the fascination sometimes exceeds the understanding. Christopher Abbott’s Adam Trask is unevenly served too, and the writing around these two characters leaves more work to the performances than it should.
Hoon Lee, playing Lee, gives the drama a steadier emotional centre. We find the attention paid to Lee’s own life and purpose moving: his tenderness has weight because the series takes an interest in him beyond his usefulness to the family. That care makes him someone worth following in his own right, and it gives the larger story more feeling. Hoon Lee deserves equal billing in the recommendation; Florence Pugh may be the immediate attraction, but there is ample reason to become attached to his character.
The visual finish is handsome, with cinematography by Sam Chiplin and Stuart Dryburgh and production design by Grant Major. The polish suits a literary family saga, making its ambition inviting rather than forbidding. Laure de Clermont-Tonnerre and Garth Davis direct, and the elegance of the presentation is a pleasure even where the characterisation is less assured. It can also encourage expectations the writing does not consistently meet, particularly when Cathy and Adam receive less convincing development than Lee.
The opening episodes are the main test of patience, with some performances less assured than the leads. Julia Bloch, Jane Rizzo and Meg Reticker share the editing credits, and the early stretch could establish the drama’s hold more firmly. Laura Karpman supplies the music, while Kirsty Cameron is responsible for costume design. The reservation is not that seven episodes are too many for a family saga; it is that the opening needs to make its characters as absorbing as the strongest performances eventually make them.
Literary television can become solemn about its responsibilities, and this series is more appealing when it allows the family drama to be absorbing entertainment. Its moral complications give us enough to consider without every character having to explain something about humanity. The unevenness matters, but it does not cancel the pleasure of performances that make difficult people worth sustained attention. Give it time if a demanding family saga appeals, and allow for an opening that takes longer than it should to earn that patience.
The reviews are uniformly positive about East of Eden, with praise clustering around Florence Pugh’s performance as Cathy Ames. Most critics find her portrayal layered and unsettling, while Hoon Lee draws repeated praise for the tenderness and emotional weight he brings to Lee. The adaptation’s literary ambition also wins support: several reviews admire its faithfulness, and others welcome the fresh attention given to its characters.
The differences concern how fully that ambition is realised, with enthusiasm ranging from qualified approval to strong endorsement. IndieWire praises the nuance of Cathy’s portrayal, but The Guardian finds her less developed than the men and sees a compelling family saga without enough depth in its examination of human nature. Elsewhere, reservations centre on uneven character development, faltering early episodes and weaker performances among the less experienced cast, rather than a rejection of the series as a whole.
Travers calls the adaptation magnificent, smart, and richly provocative. He especially praises Florence Pugh’s commanding performance and the nuanced portrayal of Cathy Ames.
Read the full review →The critic calls the series an astounding adaptation and says it sets a towering new standard for literary TV adaptations. They single out Florence Pugh’s career-best performance as Cathy and praise Hoon Lee as the family’s anchor.
Read the full review →Nugent finds the adaptation excellent and elegant, though some early episodes and less experienced actors falter. He especially praises Florence Pugh’s layered performance as Cathy and Hoon Lee’s soulful turn as Lee.
Read the full review →VanArendonk finds that the miniseries’ considerable ambition ultimately outweighs its uneven treatment of Cathy and Adam. She especially praises Hoon Lee’s tender performance and the series’ attention to his character’s life and purpose.
Read the full review →The review presents the adaptation as a gorgeously faithful, glossy retelling of the classic novel. It singles out Florence Pugh’s lead performance and the adaptation’s faithfulness for praise.
Read the full review →Mangan calls the series brilliant, compelling entertainment as a family saga, but says it lacks the heft for a deeper examination of human nature. She praises its lavish visuals and strong performances, while finding Cathy less fully developed than the men around her.
Read the full review →
The Grapes of WrathAnother Steinbeck adaptation, with family loyalty tested by poverty and displacement.
Days of HeavenFor rural American drama where desire and money make dangerous neighbours.
Howards EndFor a literary adaptation attentive to property, class and intimate betrayal.
PachinkoFor another family saga that gives several generations room to develop.
A SeparationFor family conflict that makes judging anyone a difficult business.
Free account
Two lists that know where things are streaming, collections you can share, your own score beside ours, and Discover that remembers what you have seen.
